"We debated long over the situation for it is a very difficult question and all of us recognize its difficulty"
About this Quote
A sentence like this is less a window into deliberation than a shield against history. Stimson’s “We debated long” is the classic statesman’s preface to a decision that will be questioned for decades: it asserts process. The point isn’t to tell you what was decided; it’s to establish that whatever followed was not rash, not casual, not the product of appetite or ideology. It’s an attempt to buy moral credibility in advance.
The repetition does the heavy lifting. “A very difficult question” and “all of us recognize its difficulty” doubles the claim that the burden was felt collectively. That “all of us” matters: it spreads responsibility across a committee, a Cabinet, an administration. In the language of power, unanimity functions as insulation. If everyone agrees it was hard, no one person can be blamed for finding it easy.
Stimson’s era makes the subtext louder. As Secretary of War during World War II, he spoke in the register of decisions where lives are counted in cities, not individuals. The phrase “the situation” keeps the specifics offstage; abstraction is a tool here, not a flaw. It narrows the public’s role to judging temperament (serious, sober, conscientious) rather than examining premises, alternatives, or costs.
What makes the line work is its carefully staged humility. It concedes doubt without conceding error, acknowledges anguish without yielding authority. It’s the rhetoric of democratic governance under extraordinary pressure: a plea to trust the decision-makers because they suffered while making the call.
The repetition does the heavy lifting. “A very difficult question” and “all of us recognize its difficulty” doubles the claim that the burden was felt collectively. That “all of us” matters: it spreads responsibility across a committee, a Cabinet, an administration. In the language of power, unanimity functions as insulation. If everyone agrees it was hard, no one person can be blamed for finding it easy.
Stimson’s era makes the subtext louder. As Secretary of War during World War II, he spoke in the register of decisions where lives are counted in cities, not individuals. The phrase “the situation” keeps the specifics offstage; abstraction is a tool here, not a flaw. It narrows the public’s role to judging temperament (serious, sober, conscientious) rather than examining premises, alternatives, or costs.
What makes the line work is its carefully staged humility. It concedes doubt without conceding error, acknowledges anguish without yielding authority. It’s the rhetoric of democratic governance under extraordinary pressure: a plea to trust the decision-makers because they suffered while making the call.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Henry
Add to List








