"We do not choose survival as a value, it chooses us"
About this Quote
Survival doesn t sit on the shelf of human values like honesty or beauty, waiting for us to pick it. It arrives as the silent editor of every choice we think we freely make. Skinner s line works because it flips the usual moral posture: instead of heroic agency (I decide to live), we get behavioral inevitability (living decides for me). That inversion is pure Skinner - bracing, a little deflationary, and aimed squarely at the sentimental story that people steer their lives by inner principles.
The intent is to smuggle a core behaviorist claim into a deceptively simple sentence: what we call values are often post hoc narratives layered over reinforcement histories. Organisms that don t behave as if survival matters tend not to stick around long enough to develop philosophies about it. So survival "chooses us" through selection pressures - biological evolution, cultural practices, and everyday contingencies of reward and punishment. The subtext is mildly corrosive to notions of free will: even our loftiest commitments may be downstream of a deeper, nonnegotiable sorting mechanism.
Context matters. Skinner wrote in an era when psychology was fighting over whether the mind should be treated as a black box or a sovereign commander. His broader project, especially in works like Beyond Freedom and Dignity, was to replace moralizing with engineering: design environments that shape better behavior, rather than praising willpower and blaming character. Read that way, the quote is less fatalism than a challenge. If survival is the hidden author of our "values", we should stop pretending we opted in - and start taking responsibility for the conditions that keep choosing for us.
The intent is to smuggle a core behaviorist claim into a deceptively simple sentence: what we call values are often post hoc narratives layered over reinforcement histories. Organisms that don t behave as if survival matters tend not to stick around long enough to develop philosophies about it. So survival "chooses us" through selection pressures - biological evolution, cultural practices, and everyday contingencies of reward and punishment. The subtext is mildly corrosive to notions of free will: even our loftiest commitments may be downstream of a deeper, nonnegotiable sorting mechanism.
Context matters. Skinner wrote in an era when psychology was fighting over whether the mind should be treated as a black box or a sovereign commander. His broader project, especially in works like Beyond Freedom and Dignity, was to replace moralizing with engineering: design environments that shape better behavior, rather than praising willpower and blaming character. Read that way, the quote is less fatalism than a challenge. If survival is the hidden author of our "values", we should stop pretending we opted in - and start taking responsibility for the conditions that keep choosing for us.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|
More Quotes by F. Skinner
Add to List





