"We do not know what we want and yet we are responsible for what we are - that is the fact"
About this Quote
Sartre needles the reader with a contradiction that’s meant to sting: you can be confused, even opaque to yourself, and still be on the hook. The line is built like a trap. First comes the disarming admission of fog - “We do not know what we want” - a diagnosis that sounds almost compassionate, like Sartre is granting the modern subject a break. Then he snaps the leash tight: “and yet we are responsible.” The “and yet” is the hinge where existentialism stops being a mood and becomes a demand.
The intent is not to shame people for uncertainty; it’s to deny them the refuge of it. Sartre’s larger project, especially in the 1940s, is to puncture the alibis that let ordinary life drift: tradition, God, “human nature,” even psychology as destiny. If you claim you don’t know what you want, fine - but you still chose (or passively allowed) the habits, relationships, jobs, and politics that have made you “what we are.” The subtext is that ignorance is not innocence. Confusion can be a strategy: a way of outsourcing authorship of your life to circumstances.
The phrase “that is the fact” lands with deliberate bluntness, like a verdict rather than a flourish. In postwar Europe, where “I was just following orders” hung in the air as a moral defense, Sartre insists on the uncomfortable premise that not choosing is itself a choice. Freedom isn’t celebratory here; it’s prosecutorial.
The intent is not to shame people for uncertainty; it’s to deny them the refuge of it. Sartre’s larger project, especially in the 1940s, is to puncture the alibis that let ordinary life drift: tradition, God, “human nature,” even psychology as destiny. If you claim you don’t know what you want, fine - but you still chose (or passively allowed) the habits, relationships, jobs, and politics that have made you “what we are.” The subtext is that ignorance is not innocence. Confusion can be a strategy: a way of outsourcing authorship of your life to circumstances.
The phrase “that is the fact” lands with deliberate bluntness, like a verdict rather than a flourish. In postwar Europe, where “I was just following orders” hung in the air as a moral defense, Sartre insists on the uncomfortable premise that not choosing is itself a choice. Freedom isn’t celebratory here; it’s prosecutorial.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|
More Quotes by Jean-Paul
Add to List





