"We feel much happier and more secure when we think we know precisely what to do, no matter what happens, then when we have lost our way and do not know where to turn"
About this Quote
Certainty is Clifford's comfort drug, and he describes its effect with a mathematician's dry clarity: the real seduction isn't that a plan will work, but that having one quiets the nervous system. The line turns on a sly asymmetry. "No matter what happens" should be the phrase that destabilizes us, yet Clifford pairs it with "precisely what to do", implying that procedure can anesthetize chaos. Security, in this framing, is less about safety than about legibility.
The intent is diagnostic and quietly suspicious. Clifford isn't praising rigid instruction so much as exposing why humans cling to it. We prefer an algorithm to an unknown, even if the algorithm is wrong, because it restores a sense of agency. Notice how the second half intensifies into spatial panic: "lost our way", "do not know where to turn". Uncertainty becomes disorientation, a bodily experience. The fear isn't ignorance in the abstract; it's being mid-crisis without a next step.
Context matters because Clifford made his name arguing that belief carries ethical responsibility. In essays like "The Ethics of Belief", he warns against accepting convictions on insufficient evidence. Read that alongside this quote and you get the subtext: the craving for "precise" direction is exactly what makes us vulnerable to dogma, superstition, and charismatic certainty. If comfort is the reward, truth can become optional.
He also writes as a Victorian thinker living through rapid scientific upheaval, when old metaphysical maps were being redrawn. The quote anticipates a modern problem: institutions and ideologies sell certainty because uncertainty feels like free fall. Clifford's sting is that the feeling of security is not the same thing as being secure.
The intent is diagnostic and quietly suspicious. Clifford isn't praising rigid instruction so much as exposing why humans cling to it. We prefer an algorithm to an unknown, even if the algorithm is wrong, because it restores a sense of agency. Notice how the second half intensifies into spatial panic: "lost our way", "do not know where to turn". Uncertainty becomes disorientation, a bodily experience. The fear isn't ignorance in the abstract; it's being mid-crisis without a next step.
Context matters because Clifford made his name arguing that belief carries ethical responsibility. In essays like "The Ethics of Belief", he warns against accepting convictions on insufficient evidence. Read that alongside this quote and you get the subtext: the craving for "precise" direction is exactly what makes us vulnerable to dogma, superstition, and charismatic certainty. If comfort is the reward, truth can become optional.
He also writes as a Victorian thinker living through rapid scientific upheaval, when old metaphysical maps were being redrawn. The quote anticipates a modern problem: institutions and ideologies sell certainty because uncertainty feels like free fall. Clifford's sting is that the feeling of security is not the same thing as being secure.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List







