"We have an open society. No one will come and take me away for saying what I am saying. But they don't have to, if they can control how many people hear it. And that's how they do it"
About this Quote
Browne’s line is built like a trapdoor: it starts with the comforting civic lullaby of “open society,” then drops you into the modern reality that censorship rarely needs handcuffs. The first sentence sounds almost grateful, even a little smug - a citizen noting the absence of secret police. Then he pivots to the more unnerving point: freedom of speech can be technically intact while public speech is functionally strangled.
The key move is “they don’t have to.” It reframes power as lazy, efficient, and managerial. No raids, no bans, no martyrs - just quiet throttling. “Control how many people hear it” is the whole diagnosis of a media era where gatekeeping doesn’t always look like a closed door; it looks like an algorithm, a playlist placement, a deplatforming-by-demonetization, a news cycle that buries what it can’t refute. Browne isn’t romanticizing dissent so much as warning that the audience is the real battleground. If you can’t reach people, you’re still “free,” in the narrow legal sense, but politically inert.
“And that’s how they do it” lands with a musician’s weary clarity: this isn’t theory, it’s observed practice. Coming from a songwriter whose career depended on radio, labels, and later digital distribution, the quote reads as insider testimony. The subtext is grimly democratic: the state doesn’t need to silence you if the marketplace of attention can be tuned to ignore you. The scariest censorship is the kind that lets you keep talking.
The key move is “they don’t have to.” It reframes power as lazy, efficient, and managerial. No raids, no bans, no martyrs - just quiet throttling. “Control how many people hear it” is the whole diagnosis of a media era where gatekeeping doesn’t always look like a closed door; it looks like an algorithm, a playlist placement, a deplatforming-by-demonetization, a news cycle that buries what it can’t refute. Browne isn’t romanticizing dissent so much as warning that the audience is the real battleground. If you can’t reach people, you’re still “free,” in the narrow legal sense, but politically inert.
“And that’s how they do it” lands with a musician’s weary clarity: this isn’t theory, it’s observed practice. Coming from a songwriter whose career depended on radio, labels, and later digital distribution, the quote reads as insider testimony. The subtext is grimly democratic: the state doesn’t need to silence you if the marketplace of attention can be tuned to ignore you. The scariest censorship is the kind that lets you keep talking.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Jackson
Add to List




