"We have become makers of our fate when we have ceased to pose as its prophets"
About this Quote
Popper lands the jab where modern politics and pundit culture still bruise: the urge to dress guesses up as destiny. “Prophets” aren’t just religious figures here; they’re anyone claiming history has a script - the ideologue insisting the market will inevitably purify itself, the revolutionary certain collapse is mathematically due, the technocrat promising frictionless progress. Popper’s line cuts through that seduction with a deliberately plain reversal: agency begins when you stop pretending you can see the end.
The subtext is anti-comfort. Prophecy offers psychological shelter: if the future is foretold, you’re absolved of messy responsibility. Popper refuses that bargain. “Makers” signals craft, contingency, and error - fate as something assembled from decisions, institutions, feedback loops. It’s a quiet defense of liberal democracy’s unglamorous premise: we don’t get salvation through grand historical laws, we get improvement through trial, criticism, and revision.
Context matters. Writing in the shadow of fascism and Stalinism, Popper argued that “historicism” - the belief that history unfolds by discoverable laws - fuels authoritarian certainty. If you can claim history is on your side, dissent becomes not merely wrong but “against the future.” This sentence is a pressure-release valve: it punctures inevitability so accountability can re-enter.
The intent, then, isn’t motivational poster optimism; it’s epistemic discipline. Stop narrating your preferences as fate. Admit what you don’t know. Then build, argue, and fix - because the future isn’t revealed, it’s negotiated.
The subtext is anti-comfort. Prophecy offers psychological shelter: if the future is foretold, you’re absolved of messy responsibility. Popper refuses that bargain. “Makers” signals craft, contingency, and error - fate as something assembled from decisions, institutions, feedback loops. It’s a quiet defense of liberal democracy’s unglamorous premise: we don’t get salvation through grand historical laws, we get improvement through trial, criticism, and revision.
Context matters. Writing in the shadow of fascism and Stalinism, Popper argued that “historicism” - the belief that history unfolds by discoverable laws - fuels authoritarian certainty. If you can claim history is on your side, dissent becomes not merely wrong but “against the future.” This sentence is a pressure-release valve: it punctures inevitability so accountability can re-enter.
The intent, then, isn’t motivational poster optimism; it’s epistemic discipline. Stop narrating your preferences as fate. Admit what you don’t know. Then build, argue, and fix - because the future isn’t revealed, it’s negotiated.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Karl
Add to List




