"We may not always agree with every one of our neighbors. That's life. And it's part of living in such a diverse and dense city. But we also recognize that part of being a New Yorker is living with your neighbors in mutual respect and tolerance. It was exactly that spirit of openness and acceptance that was attacked on 9/11, 2001"
About this Quote
Bloomberg’s move here is to take a mundane urban truth - your neighbor will annoy you - and weld it to a sacred civic wound: 9/11. The quote works because it scales seamlessly from the intimate to the monumental. It starts with the low-stakes friction of apartment living and subway proximity, then reframes tolerance not as a feel-good virtue but as infrastructure: the social system that lets a “diverse and dense” city function without collapsing into permanent grievance.
The intent is plainly political, but not cheaply so. Bloomberg is asserting a specific definition of “New Yorker” that sidesteps ethnicity, religion, or party and instead elevates a behavioral standard: mutual respect. That’s a canny move in a city where identity can be a battlefield; he offers belonging as a practice rather than a pedigree. In the subtext, there’s a warning to anyone tempted by backlash or scapegoating: treating neighbors as enemies isn’t just rude, it’s a capitulation to what the attackers wanted.
The 9/11 line is the emotional trapdoor. By claiming “openness and acceptance” were attacked, Bloomberg recasts terrorism as an assault on pluralism itself, not only on lives and buildings. That framing makes intolerance feel un-American and un-New York in one stroke. It’s also a bid to discipline post-crisis politics: grief is permitted, rage is understandable, but the acceptable outlet is civic solidarity, not suspicion. In Bloomberg’s New York, tolerance isn’t naive; it’s defiance.
The intent is plainly political, but not cheaply so. Bloomberg is asserting a specific definition of “New Yorker” that sidesteps ethnicity, religion, or party and instead elevates a behavioral standard: mutual respect. That’s a canny move in a city where identity can be a battlefield; he offers belonging as a practice rather than a pedigree. In the subtext, there’s a warning to anyone tempted by backlash or scapegoating: treating neighbors as enemies isn’t just rude, it’s a capitulation to what the attackers wanted.
The 9/11 line is the emotional trapdoor. By claiming “openness and acceptance” were attacked, Bloomberg recasts terrorism as an assault on pluralism itself, not only on lives and buildings. That framing makes intolerance feel un-American and un-New York in one stroke. It’s also a bid to discipline post-crisis politics: grief is permitted, rage is understandable, but the acceptable outlet is civic solidarity, not suspicion. In Bloomberg’s New York, tolerance isn’t naive; it’s defiance.
Quote Details
| Topic | Respect |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Michael
Add to List





