"We must not try to force him to take civilization immediately in its complete form, but under just laws, guaranteeing to Indians equal civil laws, the Indian question, a source of such dishonor to our country and of shame to true patriots, will soon be a thing of the past"
About this Quote
The rhetorical pivot is “just laws,” a phrase that flatters the American self-image while dodging the lived reality of federal policy: broken treaties, land grabs, coerced removals, and a legal system designed to make Native sovereignty unintelligible. “Equal civil laws” reads generous, but it’s assimilationist code. Equality here means being folded into U.S. jurisdiction, not recognizing parallel political authority. The promise is protection; the price is disappearance.
Crook’s real audience isn’t Indigenous nations. It’s “true patriots” embarrassed by the reputational cost of frontier violence. He treats the “Indian question” less as an injustice done to Native people than as a stain on the republic’s honor - “dishonor… shame” - a moral bookkeeping problem for the nation’s conscience. That’s why the solution is framed as administrative cleanup: pass the right laws, apply them evenly, and the “question” will vanish.
In context, Crook belonged to an era when the U.S. oscillated between exterminatory warfare and “humanitarian” assimilation, often in the same decade. His sentence captures that seam: a humane tone that still presumes an ending where Indigenous difference is “a thing of the past.”
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Crook, George. (2026, January 15). We must not try to force him to take civilization immediately in its complete form, but under just laws, guaranteeing to Indians equal civil laws, the Indian question, a source of such dishonor to our country and of shame to true patriots, will soon be a thing of the past. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/we-must-not-try-to-force-him-to-take-civilization-150853/
Chicago Style
Crook, George. "We must not try to force him to take civilization immediately in its complete form, but under just laws, guaranteeing to Indians equal civil laws, the Indian question, a source of such dishonor to our country and of shame to true patriots, will soon be a thing of the past." FixQuotes. January 15, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/we-must-not-try-to-force-him-to-take-civilization-150853/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"We must not try to force him to take civilization immediately in its complete form, but under just laws, guaranteeing to Indians equal civil laws, the Indian question, a source of such dishonor to our country and of shame to true patriots, will soon be a thing of the past." FixQuotes, 15 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/we-must-not-try-to-force-him-to-take-civilization-150853/. Accessed 17 Feb. 2026.



