"We need improvement in the style of performance. There is no more advantage in a musician who plays and conducts than in one who is only a beater of rhythm"
About this Quote
Liszt is taking a swipe at a very specific 19th-century vanity: the virtuoso who can’t resist turning the podium into an extension of the keyboard. Coming from the era’s most famous showman-pianist, the critique lands with delicious self-awareness. He’s not anti-flair; he’s anti-fakery. The target is the conductor who treats music as a mechanical problem of keeping bodies together in time, or worse, as a stage for personal dominance.
The key phrase is “style of performance.” Liszt isn’t talking about tempo accuracy or baton technique. He’s arguing that musical leadership is interpretive and communicative: shaping phrasing, color, balance, and intention in a way that players can feel, not just count. When he dismisses the “musician who plays and conducts,” he’s also rejecting the assumption that technical prowess automatically confers artistic authority. A performer can be brilliant and still be incapable of listening from the outside, of hearing the orchestra as an organism rather than as accompaniment.
The insult “beater of rhythm” is surgical. It strips the conductor down to a metronome with arms, a figure of pure function. That’s a warning about what happens when institutions professionalize: roles become job descriptions, and the soul gets replaced by procedure. Liszt’s subtext is that the conductor’s real advantage should be imagination and taste - the ability to make an orchestra say something, not merely arrive together at the bar line.
The key phrase is “style of performance.” Liszt isn’t talking about tempo accuracy or baton technique. He’s arguing that musical leadership is interpretive and communicative: shaping phrasing, color, balance, and intention in a way that players can feel, not just count. When he dismisses the “musician who plays and conducts,” he’s also rejecting the assumption that technical prowess automatically confers artistic authority. A performer can be brilliant and still be incapable of listening from the outside, of hearing the orchestra as an organism rather than as accompaniment.
The insult “beater of rhythm” is surgical. It strips the conductor down to a metronome with arms, a figure of pure function. That’s a warning about what happens when institutions professionalize: roles become job descriptions, and the soul gets replaced by procedure. Liszt’s subtext is that the conductor’s real advantage should be imagination and taste - the ability to make an orchestra say something, not merely arrive together at the bar line.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Franz
Add to List
