"We need to consider nominations as thoroughly and carefully as the American people deserve. No one is entitled to a free pass to a lifetime appointment to the Supreme Court"
About this Quote
Leahy’s line is built to sound procedural while doing something aggressively political: buying time and asserting leverage. “Thoroughly and carefully” is the bipartisan lullaby of Washington, the phrase everyone invokes when they want to slow-walk a process without admitting it. It frames delay as diligence, skepticism as civic duty. The move is rhetorical judo: any complaint becomes an argument against “what the American people deserve.”
The second sentence sharpens the edge. “No one is entitled” recasts a constitutional process into a moral economy. A “free pass” is the language of privilege and shortcuts, a subtly populist jab that hints the nominee (and the president who chose them) is trying to game the system. It also smuggles in a hierarchy of values: the Court is not just another job; it’s “a lifetime appointment,” a phrase meant to raise the stakes and justify exceptional scrutiny. Leahy is reminding listeners that the Senate’s consent power is not decorative.
Context matters: Leahy, a long-serving Democratic senator and former Judiciary Committee chair, is speaking from the institution that can halt a nomination by stretching “consideration” into obstruction. The subtext is about legitimacy and control. After years of nomination warfare, “careful consideration” becomes code for “we’ll decide the timetable,” and “free pass” becomes a preemptive strike against claims of unfairness. It’s a message to both audiences: to voters, we’re protecting the Court; to the White House, you don’t get to rush us.
The second sentence sharpens the edge. “No one is entitled” recasts a constitutional process into a moral economy. A “free pass” is the language of privilege and shortcuts, a subtly populist jab that hints the nominee (and the president who chose them) is trying to game the system. It also smuggles in a hierarchy of values: the Court is not just another job; it’s “a lifetime appointment,” a phrase meant to raise the stakes and justify exceptional scrutiny. Leahy is reminding listeners that the Senate’s consent power is not decorative.
Context matters: Leahy, a long-serving Democratic senator and former Judiciary Committee chair, is speaking from the institution that can halt a nomination by stretching “consideration” into obstruction. The subtext is about legitimacy and control. After years of nomination warfare, “careful consideration” becomes code for “we’ll decide the timetable,” and “free pass” becomes a preemptive strike against claims of unfairness. It’s a message to both audiences: to voters, we’re protecting the Court; to the White House, you don’t get to rush us.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Patrick
Add to List
