"We need to thank all of our troops, and particularly those for whom we can never express enough gratitude for they have given their lives so that all of us may be free and that our democracy can be a shining light for the rest of the world"
About this Quote
Gratitude is doing two jobs here: sanctifying the military and laundering a political worldview through mourning. Goode’s line starts with the broad civic reflex - “thank all of our troops” - then tightens the lens to the dead, “those for whom we can never express enough gratitude.” That move is rhetorically bulletproof: once the sacrifice is foregrounded, disagreement starts to look like disrespect. The sentence doesn’t argue a policy; it asserts a moral ledger in which “they have given their lives” purchases “our” freedom.
The subtext is an old American bargain dressed in Memorial Day language: military death equals national virtue. “So that all of us may be free” flattens the messy causes of war into a single clean outcome, collapsing Iraq, Afghanistan, Vietnam, and World War II into the same civic fable. The phrase “our democracy” is the pivot from commemoration to mission statement; it’s not just about what was defended, but what America is for. Then comes the export clause: democracy as “a shining light for the rest of the world.” That’s exceptionalism in its most polished form, implying global obligation and moral hierarchy without naming interventions, alliances, or costs.
Context matters because Goode, a conservative congressman associated with nativist and hardline positions, benefits from the unifying aura of troop praise. The statement invites a coalition - patriots, families, veterans - while inoculating the speaker against scrutiny: who decides which wars “make us free,” and who bears the burden? The language works because it turns grief into consensus and consensus into legitimacy.
The subtext is an old American bargain dressed in Memorial Day language: military death equals national virtue. “So that all of us may be free” flattens the messy causes of war into a single clean outcome, collapsing Iraq, Afghanistan, Vietnam, and World War II into the same civic fable. The phrase “our democracy” is the pivot from commemoration to mission statement; it’s not just about what was defended, but what America is for. Then comes the export clause: democracy as “a shining light for the rest of the world.” That’s exceptionalism in its most polished form, implying global obligation and moral hierarchy without naming interventions, alliances, or costs.
Context matters because Goode, a conservative congressman associated with nativist and hardline positions, benefits from the unifying aura of troop praise. The statement invites a coalition - patriots, families, veterans - while inoculating the speaker against scrutiny: who decides which wars “make us free,” and who bears the burden? The language works because it turns grief into consensus and consensus into legitimacy.
Quote Details
| Topic | Military & Soldier |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Virgil
Add to List

