"We not only heard it before 20 years ago, before George Bush in 2001 passed his tax relief, before in 2003 the tax relief were past, we were told they were dead. Before we provided prescription drugs for Medicare, we were told it wasn't going to happen"
About this Quote
Memory is doing heavy lifting here, and not the reliable kind. Ken Mehlman’s quote is built as a rewind montage: remember the doomsayers, remember the “dead on arrival” predictions, remember how we proved them wrong. It’s political jiu-jitsu, turning past skepticism into present legitimacy. If critics once said the Bush-era tax cuts and Medicare prescription drug benefit “weren’t going to happen,” then today’s objections can be framed as just the same reflexive negativity. The line isn’t trying to win an argument on policy math; it’s trying to win a battle over confidence.
The specific intent is mobilizing the base and disciplining the middle. Mehlman speaks in the collective “we,” laundering partisan choices into a shared national accomplishment. The subtext is: trust our side’s competence and stamina; distrust the people who keep predicting failure. That’s an especially useful move for a party defending controversial fiscal decisions, because it shifts the conversation away from costs, distribution, and long-term consequences. Success becomes defined as passing the bill, not whether the bill worked.
The delivery, with its clunky chronology and grammatical stumbles (“were past”), actually reinforces the vibe: this is stump-speech realism, not seminar precision. In context, Mehlman was a Republican strategist selling a narrative of governing momentum in the early 2000s, when “tax relief” and Medicare Part D were signature achievements. The quote functions like a talisman against doubt: if the last fights ended in victory, the next one should, too.
The specific intent is mobilizing the base and disciplining the middle. Mehlman speaks in the collective “we,” laundering partisan choices into a shared national accomplishment. The subtext is: trust our side’s competence and stamina; distrust the people who keep predicting failure. That’s an especially useful move for a party defending controversial fiscal decisions, because it shifts the conversation away from costs, distribution, and long-term consequences. Success becomes defined as passing the bill, not whether the bill worked.
The delivery, with its clunky chronology and grammatical stumbles (“were past”), actually reinforces the vibe: this is stump-speech realism, not seminar precision. In context, Mehlman was a Republican strategist selling a narrative of governing momentum in the early 2000s, when “tax relief” and Medicare Part D were signature achievements. The quote functions like a talisman against doubt: if the last fights ended in victory, the next one should, too.
Quote Details
| Topic | Perseverance |
|---|
More Quotes by Ken
Add to List
