"We ought instead of retreating should follow up the enemy and take Richmond. And in full view of all responsible for such declaration, I say to you all, such an order can only be prompted by cowardice or treason"
About this Quote
Kearny’s line reads like a battlefield telegram dipped in contempt: not just a tactical disagreement, but an accusation meant to scorch reputations. The immediate intent is blunt pressure. “We ought” isn’t gentle advice; it’s a claim of obviousness, framing any alternative as willful failure. By naming Richmond, he invokes the war’s magnetic objective in 1862: the capital as shortcut to victory, the symbol that made patience look like weakness. “Follow up the enemy” carries a soldier’s instinct for momentum, the belief that hesitation after contact is how wars drag on and bodies pile up.
The subtext is where the knife goes in. Kearny doesn’t argue that retreat is mistaken; he argues that ordering it is morally illegitimate. “Only be prompted by cowardice or treason” collapses a spectrum of strategic caution into two crimes: fear or betrayal. That move weaponizes honor culture inside the Union high command, where generals were not just planners but public figures under political scrutiny. He’s speaking “in full view of all responsible,” turning critique into a performative act meant to circulate, to force witnesses to pick sides, to make the order’s authors feel the heat of collective judgment.
Context matters: early Union campaigns were marked by overcaution, muddled command, and punishing public expectations. Kearny, an aggressive commander with a reputation for audacity, channels the frustration of a North tired of retreats that looked, to civilians, like incompetence. The rhetoric works because it makes strategy inseparable from character; it dares leadership to prove its loyalty by advancing.
The subtext is where the knife goes in. Kearny doesn’t argue that retreat is mistaken; he argues that ordering it is morally illegitimate. “Only be prompted by cowardice or treason” collapses a spectrum of strategic caution into two crimes: fear or betrayal. That move weaponizes honor culture inside the Union high command, where generals were not just planners but public figures under political scrutiny. He’s speaking “in full view of all responsible,” turning critique into a performative act meant to circulate, to force witnesses to pick sides, to make the order’s authors feel the heat of collective judgment.
Context matters: early Union campaigns were marked by overcaution, muddled command, and punishing public expectations. Kearny, an aggressive commander with a reputation for audacity, channels the frustration of a North tired of retreats that looked, to civilians, like incompetence. The rhetoric works because it makes strategy inseparable from character; it dares leadership to prove its loyalty by advancing.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Philip
Add to List
