"We photographers deal in things which are continually vanishing, and when they have vanished there is no contrivance on earth can make them come back again. We cannot develop and print a memory"
About this Quote
Cartier-Bresson turns photography into a craft haunted by loss. The line isn’t nostalgic; it’s almost clinical in its reminder that the camera’s raw material is disappearance. A street corner empties, a face changes, a political moment hardens into history. The photographer’s job is to bargain with time using fractions of a second, knowing the bargain always favors time.
The phrasing does crucial work. “Deal in things” makes image-making sound like trade or contraband: photographers traffic in the fleeting. “Continually vanishing” strips away any romantic fantasy that reality holds still for art. Then the hard stop: “no contrivance on earth.” That word choice rejects both technology and cleverness as saviors. Better lenses, faster shutters, new formats - none of it resurrects what you missed. It’s a warning aimed at the overconfident technician.
The subtext is also a quiet argument against sentimental myths about photos as “memory.” Cartier-Bresson, father of the “decisive moment,” insists the decisive moment cannot be retroactively manufactured. You can’t “develop and print a memory” because memory isn’t a negative waiting in the darkroom; it’s unstable, biased, rewritten. Photography can fix a surface, not restore an interior life.
Context matters: coming out of the 20th century’s convulsions - war, upheaval, rapid modernity - Cartier-Bresson understood that history doesn’t pose. His remark reads like an ethic: pay attention, be present, because the world isn’t obligated to repeat itself for your art.
The phrasing does crucial work. “Deal in things” makes image-making sound like trade or contraband: photographers traffic in the fleeting. “Continually vanishing” strips away any romantic fantasy that reality holds still for art. Then the hard stop: “no contrivance on earth.” That word choice rejects both technology and cleverness as saviors. Better lenses, faster shutters, new formats - none of it resurrects what you missed. It’s a warning aimed at the overconfident technician.
The subtext is also a quiet argument against sentimental myths about photos as “memory.” Cartier-Bresson, father of the “decisive moment,” insists the decisive moment cannot be retroactively manufactured. You can’t “develop and print a memory” because memory isn’t a negative waiting in the darkroom; it’s unstable, biased, rewritten. Photography can fix a surface, not restore an interior life.
Context matters: coming out of the 20th century’s convulsions - war, upheaval, rapid modernity - Cartier-Bresson understood that history doesn’t pose. His remark reads like an ethic: pay attention, be present, because the world isn’t obligated to repeat itself for your art.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Henri
Add to List
