"We recognized in 1996 that, with progress in the field of genetics accelerating at a breathtaking pace, we need to ensure that advances in treatment and prevention of disease do not constitute a new basis for discrimination"
About this Quote
Snowe’s line is a politician’s warning shot dressed as reassurance: the future is coming fast, and we’d better decide what kind of country greets it. Placing the marker in 1996 matters. This is the decade when genetics stopped being sci-fi set dressing and became policy-relevant reality: the Human Genome Project was underway, genetic tests were entering clinics, and insurers and employers were eyeing risk profiles with the enthusiasm of accountants. “Breathtaking pace” isn’t just awe; it’s a subtle admission that lawmakers were already behind.
The sentence pivots on a quiet dread: that medicine’s promise can be repurposed as a sorting mechanism. Snowe frames “treatment and prevention” - the language of public good - as the very tools that could harden inequality. That’s the subtext that gives the quote its bite. The danger isn’t rogue scientists; it’s ordinary institutions doing what they always do: pricing, screening, excluding, rationalizing it as efficiency. By calling discrimination a “new basis,” she signals a shift from older stigmas (race, disability, class) to a cleaner, more bureaucratic prejudice: the genome as destiny, backed by paperwork.
Her “we need to ensure” is classic legislative pragmatism, but it also spreads responsibility. It’s an appeal to collective stewardship, anticipating the ethics-and-regulation fights that would culminate in protections like the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act years later. Snowe isn’t celebrating innovation; she’s trying to keep the benefits from becoming a gatekeeping technology, where knowing more about your body becomes a reason to be punished for it.
The sentence pivots on a quiet dread: that medicine’s promise can be repurposed as a sorting mechanism. Snowe frames “treatment and prevention” - the language of public good - as the very tools that could harden inequality. That’s the subtext that gives the quote its bite. The danger isn’t rogue scientists; it’s ordinary institutions doing what they always do: pricing, screening, excluding, rationalizing it as efficiency. By calling discrimination a “new basis,” she signals a shift from older stigmas (race, disability, class) to a cleaner, more bureaucratic prejudice: the genome as destiny, backed by paperwork.
Her “we need to ensure” is classic legislative pragmatism, but it also spreads responsibility. It’s an appeal to collective stewardship, anticipating the ethics-and-regulation fights that would culminate in protections like the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act years later. Snowe isn’t celebrating innovation; she’s trying to keep the benefits from becoming a gatekeeping technology, where knowing more about your body becomes a reason to be punished for it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by Olympia
Add to List
