"We see an extensive program of dismantling state institutions... These are ingredients for catastrophe"
About this Quote
The line lands like a warning flare from someone who knows how quickly “reform” can be repackaged as demolition. Allawi’s phrasing does two things at once: it treats institutional collapse as an engineered process (“an extensive program”), not an accident, and it frames the outcome as almost chemically inevitable (“ingredients for catastrophe”). That’s a statesman’s rhetoric at its most pointed - cautious enough to sound responsible, sharp enough to assign agency without naming every culprit.
Context matters. Allawi is not a distant commentator; he’s a post-2003 Iraqi political actor speaking from inside a state remade under occupation, sectarian bargaining, and competing militias. In that environment, “dismantling” can refer to de-Baathification and the dissolution of the army, but also to the quieter hollowing-out that follows: ministries turned into party fiefdoms, patronage replacing expertise, security forces fragmented into loyalist units. The subtext is that the state isn’t merely weak; it’s being actively unstitched by policies that confuse purification with governance.
The quote’s intent is preventative, but it’s also accusatory in a diplomat’s register. “Ingredients” implies a recipe, and recipes have cooks. Allawi signals that catastrophe will later be narrated as fate - civil war, insurgency, criminal corruption - unless people recognize the early-stage choices that make it predictable. He’s trying to shift the public argument from personalities and scandals to infrastructure: who controls institutions, who empties them, and who benefits when the state can no longer keep order, deliver services, or claim legitimacy.
Context matters. Allawi is not a distant commentator; he’s a post-2003 Iraqi political actor speaking from inside a state remade under occupation, sectarian bargaining, and competing militias. In that environment, “dismantling” can refer to de-Baathification and the dissolution of the army, but also to the quieter hollowing-out that follows: ministries turned into party fiefdoms, patronage replacing expertise, security forces fragmented into loyalist units. The subtext is that the state isn’t merely weak; it’s being actively unstitched by policies that confuse purification with governance.
The quote’s intent is preventative, but it’s also accusatory in a diplomat’s register. “Ingredients” implies a recipe, and recipes have cooks. Allawi signals that catastrophe will later be narrated as fate - civil war, insurgency, criminal corruption - unless people recognize the early-stage choices that make it predictable. He’s trying to shift the public argument from personalities and scandals to infrastructure: who controls institutions, who empties them, and who benefits when the state can no longer keep order, deliver services, or claim legitimacy.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Iyad
Add to List







