"We see that every external motion, act, gesture, whether voluntary or mechanical, organic or mental, is produced and preceded by internal feeling or emotion, will or volition, and thought or mind"
About this Quote
Blavatsky is trying to flip the usual hierarchy of explanation: the body is not the primary fact of human life but its afterimage. Every twitch, decision, ritual, and reflex becomes, in her framing, a downstream effect of an inner weather system - feeling, will, thought. It’s a maximal claim, and that’s the point. The sentence doesn’t argue cautiously; it declares jurisdiction. By stacking pairs like “voluntary or mechanical, organic or mental,” she attempts to annex the whole human machine, from the knee-jerk to the moral choice, into a single interior cause.
The subtext is polemical. In the late 19th century, physiology and emerging psychology were busy mapping behavior onto nerves, brains, and stimulus-response mechanics. Blavatsky, as the Theosophy founder, rejects a strictly materialist story without sounding like she’s merely preaching soul-talk. Notice the strategic breadth of her categories: “emotion, will, thought” reads less like a clinical model than a spiritual anatomy, a way of smuggling metaphysics into the language of causation.
Rhetorically, the sentence works by making “internal” feel inevitable: “produced and preceded” doubles the causality, insisting not just on correlation but on primacy. It also collapses distinctions modern readers might guard - reflex vs intention, body vs mind - because her project depends on continuity. If all action is first inner action, then self-mastery becomes the master technology: change consciousness, and the world (including the body) follows. That’s not just philosophy; it’s a recruitment pitch for an entire cosmology.
The subtext is polemical. In the late 19th century, physiology and emerging psychology were busy mapping behavior onto nerves, brains, and stimulus-response mechanics. Blavatsky, as the Theosophy founder, rejects a strictly materialist story without sounding like she’s merely preaching soul-talk. Notice the strategic breadth of her categories: “emotion, will, thought” reads less like a clinical model than a spiritual anatomy, a way of smuggling metaphysics into the language of causation.
Rhetorically, the sentence works by making “internal” feel inevitable: “produced and preceded” doubles the causality, insisting not just on correlation but on primacy. It also collapses distinctions modern readers might guard - reflex vs intention, body vs mind - because her project depends on continuity. If all action is first inner action, then self-mastery becomes the master technology: change consciousness, and the world (including the body) follows. That’s not just philosophy; it’s a recruitment pitch for an entire cosmology.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|
More Quotes by P. Blavatsky
Add to List




