"We should not forget, no matter how we quantify it: 'Freedom is not free.' It is a painful lesson, but one from which we have learned in the past and one we should never forget"
About this Quote
Gillmor reaches for a slogan so familiar it risks becoming background noise, then tries to bolt consequence back onto it. "Freedom is not free" is political boilerplate, yes, but in his mouth it’s doing a particular job: laundering a moral claim into an accounting metaphor. He nods at "how we quantify it" to preempt the spreadsheet argument - dollars, casualties, polling, approval ratings - and then insists those measurements miss the point. The line is built to win before the debate starts: if you question the cost, you’re positioned as someone who’s forgotten the lesson.
The subtext is disciplined and unmistakable: sacrifice is inevitable, and dissent can look like amnesia. "Painful lesson" frames loss as instructive rather than accidental; suffering becomes tuition paid to history. That’s a rhetorically potent move for a politician, because it converts messy policy choices into a solemn civic ritual. It also blurs agency. Costs are treated as the natural price of "freedom", not the result of particular strategies, votes, or wars.
Context matters. Gillmor’s career sits in the post-9/11 era when "freedom" was the master word used to justify prolonged conflict and expanded security powers. His phrasing offers reassurance to constituents asked to absorb casualties and trade-offs: what hurts is what proves we’re serious. The quote works because it harnesses national memory - "we have learned in the past" - without naming the specific past, letting listeners plug in their preferred war, their preferred heroism, their preferred grief.
The subtext is disciplined and unmistakable: sacrifice is inevitable, and dissent can look like amnesia. "Painful lesson" frames loss as instructive rather than accidental; suffering becomes tuition paid to history. That’s a rhetorically potent move for a politician, because it converts messy policy choices into a solemn civic ritual. It also blurs agency. Costs are treated as the natural price of "freedom", not the result of particular strategies, votes, or wars.
Context matters. Gillmor’s career sits in the post-9/11 era when "freedom" was the master word used to justify prolonged conflict and expanded security powers. His phrasing offers reassurance to constituents asked to absorb casualties and trade-offs: what hurts is what proves we’re serious. The quote works because it harnesses national memory - "we have learned in the past" - without naming the specific past, letting listeners plug in their preferred war, their preferred heroism, their preferred grief.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Paul
Add to List
