"We shouldn't accept things just because somebody says so"
About this Quote
A politician warning you not to accept things just because somebody says so is either bracingly principled or slyly self-protective. Dixie Lee Ray’s line works because it performs a neat inversion of the job title: public officials trade in persuasion, messaging, authority. Ray’s sentence pretends to step outside that machinery and invite the listener into a shared suspicion of it.
The intent is plainly democratic: demand evidence, not deference. It’s a pocket-sized defense against propaganda, credential-worship, and the lazy comfort of “they must know better.” But the subtext is more pointed. “Somebody” is deliberately vague, allowing the target to shift depending on the audience: federal agencies, scientific experts, the press, political opponents, even the speaker’s own party leadership. That ambiguity makes the quote portable, a rhetorical Swiss Army knife.
Ray’s context matters. As Washington’s governor in an era when environmental regulation and nuclear policy were flashpoints, she often positioned herself against what she framed as technocratic overreach. Read there, the line can be heard as a populist check on expert power: don’t let bureaucratic certainty substitute for public scrutiny. That’s admirable when it sharpens accountability; it’s corrosive when it becomes a license to dismiss expertise as mere opinion.
The quote’s power comes from its simple moral posture - skepticism as civic virtue - while quietly flattering the listener: you’re not a sucker. It doesn’t tell you what to believe. It tells you you’re the kind of person who doesn’t just believe.
The intent is plainly democratic: demand evidence, not deference. It’s a pocket-sized defense against propaganda, credential-worship, and the lazy comfort of “they must know better.” But the subtext is more pointed. “Somebody” is deliberately vague, allowing the target to shift depending on the audience: federal agencies, scientific experts, the press, political opponents, even the speaker’s own party leadership. That ambiguity makes the quote portable, a rhetorical Swiss Army knife.
Ray’s context matters. As Washington’s governor in an era when environmental regulation and nuclear policy were flashpoints, she often positioned herself against what she framed as technocratic overreach. Read there, the line can be heard as a populist check on expert power: don’t let bureaucratic certainty substitute for public scrutiny. That’s admirable when it sharpens accountability; it’s corrosive when it becomes a license to dismiss expertise as mere opinion.
The quote’s power comes from its simple moral posture - skepticism as civic virtue - while quietly flattering the listener: you’re not a sucker. It doesn’t tell you what to believe. It tells you you’re the kind of person who doesn’t just believe.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Dixie
Add to List




