"We sometimes congratulate ourselves at the moment of waking from a troubled dream; it may be so the moment after death"
About this Quote
Waking up is Hawthorne's sly rehearsal for the biggest plot twist imaginable: that death might feel less like obliteration than relief. The line works because it borrows the most ordinary human reset button (the morning after a nightmare) and quietly applies it to the one event we refuse to domesticate. In that move, Hawthorne smuggles metaphysics into psychology. He doesn't argue for an afterlife; he tempts you with a sensation you already trust: the bodily, almost smug gratitude of realizing the terror wasn't real.
The subtext is pure Hawthorne: sin, guilt, and moral claustrophobia as a kind of bad dream we mistake for the whole world. In his fiction, people don't just do wrong; they live inside the atmosphere of wrongness, carrying inherited shame like a family heirloom. So the "congratulate ourselves" lands with a faint acid irony. Even our relief is self-regarding, a little vain: we pat ourselves on the back for surviving a phantom. Extend that habit past the grave and you get a bracing possibility - death as liberation from the mind's punitive theater, from the social and spiritual surveillance that his Puritan New England breathed into daily life.
Context matters: Hawthorne is writing in a 19th-century culture where Calvinist dread and emerging Romantic inwardness coexist uneasily. This sentence sits right on that fault line. It offers comfort without certainty, a hopeful hypothesis phrased as an afterthought, and its power comes from refusing to be sermon or proof. It's a novelist's wager: if life can trap us in nightmares we call reality, maybe reality has one more awakening left.
The subtext is pure Hawthorne: sin, guilt, and moral claustrophobia as a kind of bad dream we mistake for the whole world. In his fiction, people don't just do wrong; they live inside the atmosphere of wrongness, carrying inherited shame like a family heirloom. So the "congratulate ourselves" lands with a faint acid irony. Even our relief is self-regarding, a little vain: we pat ourselves on the back for surviving a phantom. Extend that habit past the grave and you get a bracing possibility - death as liberation from the mind's punitive theater, from the social and spiritual surveillance that his Puritan New England breathed into daily life.
Context matters: Hawthorne is writing in a 19th-century culture where Calvinist dread and emerging Romantic inwardness coexist uneasily. This sentence sits right on that fault line. It offers comfort without certainty, a hopeful hypothesis phrased as an afterthought, and its power comes from refusing to be sermon or proof. It's a novelist's wager: if life can trap us in nightmares we call reality, maybe reality has one more awakening left.
Quote Details
| Topic | Mortality |
|---|
More Quotes by Nathaniel
Add to List
