"We wanted to be as expansive as possible to make sure we didn't preclude some good ideas"
About this Quote
Expansive is the kind of bureaucratic halo word that makes a decision sound both generous and inevitable. In John Poindexter's mouth, it doubles as insulation: the posture of openness that also quietly evades responsibility for whatever comes next. "We wanted" spreads agency across a committee-shaped fog, and "as possible" signals constraint without naming who imposed it. The sentence performs public service's favorite trick: presenting discretion as diligence.
The intent is managerial and preemptive. Poindexter isn't selling a particular idea; he's selling the process that will later authorize one. By framing the goal as not "preclud[ing] some good ideas", he casts the future as a minefield of missed opportunities, and the institution as the careful actor scanning for them. It's a subtle reversal: the threat isn't overreach, it's narrowness. That rhetorical move justifies wide latitude in the present while borrowing legitimacy from hypothetical brilliance down the road.
The subtext is that "good ideas" are not self-evident; they're whatever can survive the internal machinery of approval, secrecy, and politics. "Expansive" becomes a synonym for broad mandates, flexible rules, and room to maneuver - the conditions under which ambitious programs can be built and defended. Coming from a career public servant whose name is inseparable from late-20th-century national security controversy, the line reads as more than harmless brainstorming. It's a window into how institutions narrate power: not as desire, but as due diligence, not as reach, but as responsibility to keep options open.
The intent is managerial and preemptive. Poindexter isn't selling a particular idea; he's selling the process that will later authorize one. By framing the goal as not "preclud[ing] some good ideas", he casts the future as a minefield of missed opportunities, and the institution as the careful actor scanning for them. It's a subtle reversal: the threat isn't overreach, it's narrowness. That rhetorical move justifies wide latitude in the present while borrowing legitimacy from hypothetical brilliance down the road.
The subtext is that "good ideas" are not self-evident; they're whatever can survive the internal machinery of approval, secrecy, and politics. "Expansive" becomes a synonym for broad mandates, flexible rules, and room to maneuver - the conditions under which ambitious programs can be built and defended. Coming from a career public servant whose name is inseparable from late-20th-century national security controversy, the line reads as more than harmless brainstorming. It's a window into how institutions narrate power: not as desire, but as due diligence, not as reach, but as responsibility to keep options open.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List




