"We were told this war would be over in a matter of weeks, and that the Iraqis would be able to finance it with oil sales. We were promised it was not a mission of nation building"
About this Quote
Sherrod Brown invokes the gulf between the rosy promises that sold the Iraq invasion and the grinding reality that followed. The line strings together three tidy assurances that softened public resistance: a quick, decisive campaign; a bill footed by Iraqi oil rather than American taxpayers; and a limited mission that would stop short of nation building. Each claim lowered the perceived cost, duration, and moral complexity of war, turning a high-risk enterprise into something marketed as manageable.
Those assurances echoed prominent voices of the time. Officials spoke of weeks, not years. Some suggested oil revenues would cover reconstruction. George W. Bush had campaigned against nation building, a phrase meant to signal restraint. Yet the fall of Saddam Hussein created a vacuum that demanded exactly what had been disavowed: a protracted occupation, the rebuilding of shattered institutions, and the navigation of deep sectarian fractures. Policy choices such as dissolving the Iraqi army and sweeping de-Baathification compounded the chaos, fueling an insurgency and forcing a long, costly presence that culminated in the surge. The war consumed thousands of American lives, hundreds of thousands of Iraqi lives, and trillions of dollars, with interest, medical care, and disability payments extending the ledger far into the future. Oil did not pay the bill; families and taxpayers did.
Brown’s phrasing also serves a democratic purpose. We were told signals a collective memory and a breached public trust, without getting bogged down in partisan scorekeeping. It highlights how optimistic narratives can narrow debate and mute skepticism at the moment when it is most needed. The critique is not only about faulty forecasts but about the ethics of policymaking by wishful thinking. If leaders promise speed, self-financing, and simplicity, they owe the public a plan for the long haul and a sober accounting of risks. The line stands as a cautionary marker: do not confuse salesmanship with strategy, and never start a war you have not planned to finish.
Those assurances echoed prominent voices of the time. Officials spoke of weeks, not years. Some suggested oil revenues would cover reconstruction. George W. Bush had campaigned against nation building, a phrase meant to signal restraint. Yet the fall of Saddam Hussein created a vacuum that demanded exactly what had been disavowed: a protracted occupation, the rebuilding of shattered institutions, and the navigation of deep sectarian fractures. Policy choices such as dissolving the Iraqi army and sweeping de-Baathification compounded the chaos, fueling an insurgency and forcing a long, costly presence that culminated in the surge. The war consumed thousands of American lives, hundreds of thousands of Iraqi lives, and trillions of dollars, with interest, medical care, and disability payments extending the ledger far into the future. Oil did not pay the bill; families and taxpayers did.
Brown’s phrasing also serves a democratic purpose. We were told signals a collective memory and a breached public trust, without getting bogged down in partisan scorekeeping. It highlights how optimistic narratives can narrow debate and mute skepticism at the moment when it is most needed. The critique is not only about faulty forecasts but about the ethics of policymaking by wishful thinking. If leaders promise speed, self-financing, and simplicity, they owe the public a plan for the long haul and a sober accounting of risks. The line stands as a cautionary marker: do not confuse salesmanship with strategy, and never start a war you have not planned to finish.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Sherrod
Add to List
