"We will look upon the earth and her sister planets as being with us, not for us. One does not rape a sister"
About this Quote
Mary Daly doesn’t “compare” planetary ethics to family; she weaponizes the comparison to make exploitation sound as grotesque as it is. The line pivots on a deliberate tonal trap: it begins with the mild, almost pastoral correction of anthropocentrism - the earth and “her sister planets” are “with us, not for us” - then snaps into a jarring moral verdict. By choosing “rape,” Daly forces the reader out of the comfortable language of “resources,” “use,” and “development” and into a register where consent, violation, and domination are the only honest terms left.
The sister metaphor is doing double work. It rejects the old Western theological habit of treating creation as a stage built for human salvation, while also indicting patriarchy’s intimate logic: the entitlement to take what is “yours,” the habit of calling possession “stewardship,” the reflex to spiritualize harm. Daly’s background in feminist theology matters here; she spent her career attacking God-talk and institutional Christianity when they function as cover for male supremacy. In that context, “One does not rape a sister” reads like a refusal of both environmental plunder and the cultural script that normalizes sexual violence through euphemism and hierarchy.
The subtext is intentionally accusatory: if you can imagine the moral line with family, why can’t you see it with the planet that sustains you? Daly’s rhetorical ruthlessness is the point. She’s not asking for greener manners; she’s naming an ethic of kinship where extraction becomes unthinkable because it’s recoded as incestuous violence.
The sister metaphor is doing double work. It rejects the old Western theological habit of treating creation as a stage built for human salvation, while also indicting patriarchy’s intimate logic: the entitlement to take what is “yours,” the habit of calling possession “stewardship,” the reflex to spiritualize harm. Daly’s background in feminist theology matters here; she spent her career attacking God-talk and institutional Christianity when they function as cover for male supremacy. In that context, “One does not rape a sister” reads like a refusal of both environmental plunder and the cultural script that normalizes sexual violence through euphemism and hierarchy.
The subtext is intentionally accusatory: if you can imagine the moral line with family, why can’t you see it with the planet that sustains you? Daly’s rhetorical ruthlessness is the point. She’s not asking for greener manners; she’s naming an ethic of kinship where extraction becomes unthinkable because it’s recoded as incestuous violence.
Quote Details
| Topic | Respect |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Mary
Add to List





