"We'd all like a reputation for generosity, and we'd all like to buy it cheap"
About this Quote
Generosity, McLaughlin suggests, is less a virtue than a brand strategy. The line lands because it admits a slightly shameful truth: many of us aren’t only motivated to give; we’re motivated to be seen giving. “Reputation” is the tell. It pulls the action out of the moral realm and into the social marketplace, where every good deed is also a bid for status, belonging, or absolution.
Then she twists the knife with “buy it cheap.” The verb “buy” treats virtue like a commodity, something you can acquire with a minimal transaction instead of sustained character. That’s the subtext: we want the glow of generosity without the cost that makes generosity meaningful. Cheapness isn’t just about money; it’s about effort, attention, risk. It’s the desire for maximum moral credit at minimum personal inconvenience.
McLaughlin, a mid-century American journalist known for crisp, aphoristic candor, was writing in a culture increasingly fluent in public relations and consumption. Her sentence reads like a miniature critique of postwar respectability: the scramble to appear decent, civic-minded, charitable, while keeping the ledger balanced. It anticipates the modern performance economy too, where a donation can double as content and compassion can be optimized for visibility.
The elegance is how she indicts without sermonizing. She includes herself (“we’d all”), making it a diagnosis of human nature rather than a scold. The humor isn’t a punchline; it’s a pressure release that lets the uncomfortable recognition slip in.
Then she twists the knife with “buy it cheap.” The verb “buy” treats virtue like a commodity, something you can acquire with a minimal transaction instead of sustained character. That’s the subtext: we want the glow of generosity without the cost that makes generosity meaningful. Cheapness isn’t just about money; it’s about effort, attention, risk. It’s the desire for maximum moral credit at minimum personal inconvenience.
McLaughlin, a mid-century American journalist known for crisp, aphoristic candor, was writing in a culture increasingly fluent in public relations and consumption. Her sentence reads like a miniature critique of postwar respectability: the scramble to appear decent, civic-minded, charitable, while keeping the ledger balanced. It anticipates the modern performance economy too, where a donation can double as content and compassion can be optimized for visibility.
The elegance is how she indicts without sermonizing. She includes herself (“we’d all”), making it a diagnosis of human nature rather than a scold. The humor isn’t a punchline; it’s a pressure release that lets the uncomfortable recognition slip in.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Mignon
Add to List




