"Well, I'm not excusing the fact that planning and preparedness was not where it should be. We've known for 20 years about this hurricane, this possibility of this kind of hurricane"
About this Quote
Chertoff’s sentence performs a familiar Washington contortion: admit failure while trying to keep culpability airborne. “I’m not excusing” is the rhetorical seatbelt politicians buckle before they swerve. It signals accountability, but it’s also a preface to a softer landing, where error becomes atmospheric rather than authored.
The real work happens in the grammar. “Planning and preparedness was not where it should be” avoids naming who planned, who prepared, who signed off. The passive tone turns decision-making into a misplaced object, as if readiness simply wandered off. That vagueness isn’t accidental; it’s a bureaucratic survival tactic. If no one is the subject, no one is fully responsible.
Then comes the most revealing pivot: “We’ve known for 20 years.” In one move, Chertoff expands the timeline and dissolves the boundaries of individual blame. “We” becomes a collective smear across agencies, administrations, experts, voters - a national shrug. It’s also a tacit admission that the disaster wasn’t a bolt from the blue; it was forecast, modeled, gamed out. The subtext is brutal: failure here isn’t ignorance, it’s neglect.
Context sharpens the edge. Speaking as a homeland security leader in the post-9/11 era, Chertoff is trapped between a public promised safety and a system built on political incentives that reward visible security theater over unglamorous infrastructure and contingency planning. The quote is less a confession than a portrait of how accountability is managed: acknowledged in principle, redistributed in practice.
The real work happens in the grammar. “Planning and preparedness was not where it should be” avoids naming who planned, who prepared, who signed off. The passive tone turns decision-making into a misplaced object, as if readiness simply wandered off. That vagueness isn’t accidental; it’s a bureaucratic survival tactic. If no one is the subject, no one is fully responsible.
Then comes the most revealing pivot: “We’ve known for 20 years.” In one move, Chertoff expands the timeline and dissolves the boundaries of individual blame. “We” becomes a collective smear across agencies, administrations, experts, voters - a national shrug. It’s also a tacit admission that the disaster wasn’t a bolt from the blue; it was forecast, modeled, gamed out. The subtext is brutal: failure here isn’t ignorance, it’s neglect.
Context sharpens the edge. Speaking as a homeland security leader in the post-9/11 era, Chertoff is trapped between a public promised safety and a system built on political incentives that reward visible security theater over unglamorous infrastructure and contingency planning. The quote is less a confession than a portrait of how accountability is managed: acknowledged in principle, redistributed in practice.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Michael
Add to List

