"Well, I'm not saying that we're solving every problem or arresting every person that ought to be arrested and deported, but we're doing a better job than has been done in the past"
About this Quote
The art here is in how a hardline message gets smuggled in under the soft blanket of modesty. Cochran opens with an almost performative shrug - "I'm not saying" - a ritual disclaimer that signals reasonableness while quietly widening the policy horizon to something far more sweeping. By conceding imperfection ("every problem", "every person"), he lowers the bar for proof and raises the bar for critique: any opponent can now be painted as demanding the impossible.
Then comes the tell: "ought to be arrested and deported". That phrase isn’t just descriptive; it’s a moral verdict slipped into bureaucratic grammar. "Ought" presumes a shared consensus about who belongs and who deserves removal, flattening messy realities (due process, mixed-status families, labor dependence) into a tidy category of people who simply need to go. The line treats deportation not as a contested political choice but as an overdue administrative task.
The closing move - "we're doing a better job than has been done in the past" - is comparative politics at its most slippery. It dodges measurable commitments and invites a nostalgic baseline: whatever your anxieties about borders, crime, or cultural change, the present administration is finally taking you seriously. In the late-20th/early-21st century immigration debates Cochran inhabited, this was a familiar Southern Republican posture: signal toughness for a base keyed to enforcement while keeping the language polished enough to pass as managerial competence. The subtext is clear: enforcement is the default good, and the only real argument left is whether we’re enforcing it hard enough.
Then comes the tell: "ought to be arrested and deported". That phrase isn’t just descriptive; it’s a moral verdict slipped into bureaucratic grammar. "Ought" presumes a shared consensus about who belongs and who deserves removal, flattening messy realities (due process, mixed-status families, labor dependence) into a tidy category of people who simply need to go. The line treats deportation not as a contested political choice but as an overdue administrative task.
The closing move - "we're doing a better job than has been done in the past" - is comparative politics at its most slippery. It dodges measurable commitments and invites a nostalgic baseline: whatever your anxieties about borders, crime, or cultural change, the present administration is finally taking you seriously. In the late-20th/early-21st century immigration debates Cochran inhabited, this was a familiar Southern Republican posture: signal toughness for a base keyed to enforcement while keeping the language polished enough to pass as managerial competence. The subtext is clear: enforcement is the default good, and the only real argument left is whether we’re enforcing it hard enough.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Thad
Add to List





