"We're all idealistic when young"
About this Quote
"We're all idealistic when young" lands like a shrug, but it’s a sharpened one. Coming from Pat Oliphant, a cartoonist whose stock-in-trade is puncturing self-importance with a single stroke, the line reads less as a tender reminiscence than as a quiet indictment. The inclusive "we're all" pretends to be generous, even consoling. It’s also a trap: by universalizing youthful idealism, the phrase smuggles in the idea that abandoning it is normal, inevitable, maybe even mature.
That’s the subtext Oliphant’s audience is meant to hear, especially in the political eras he spent skewering: Vietnam and Watergate cynicism, Reagan-era optimism-as-branding, the long slide into cable-news tribalism. In that context, "idealistic when young" can function as an alibi for the older establishment. If idealism is just a phase, then the compromises, sellouts, and bureaucratic dead ends aren’t failures; they’re adulthood.
Cartoonists are masters of compression, and this sentence works the way a good panel does: it sets up a familiar sentiment, then lets the reader supply the uncomfortable punchline. It also hints at a more sympathetic reading. If everyone starts idealistic, then cynicism isn’t wisdom; it’s learned behavior, trained by incentives and disappointments. Oliphant’s point isn’t to romanticize youth. It’s to question why our political culture treats the erosion of principles as a rite of passage rather than a problem worth satirizing.
That’s the subtext Oliphant’s audience is meant to hear, especially in the political eras he spent skewering: Vietnam and Watergate cynicism, Reagan-era optimism-as-branding, the long slide into cable-news tribalism. In that context, "idealistic when young" can function as an alibi for the older establishment. If idealism is just a phase, then the compromises, sellouts, and bureaucratic dead ends aren’t failures; they’re adulthood.
Cartoonists are masters of compression, and this sentence works the way a good panel does: it sets up a familiar sentiment, then lets the reader supply the uncomfortable punchline. It also hints at a more sympathetic reading. If everyone starts idealistic, then cynicism isn’t wisdom; it’s learned behavior, trained by incentives and disappointments. Oliphant’s point isn’t to romanticize youth. It’s to question why our political culture treats the erosion of principles as a rite of passage rather than a problem worth satirizing.
Quote Details
| Topic | Youth |
|---|
More Quotes by Pat
Add to List






