"We're here so that Afghanistan does not once again become a sanctuary for transnational extremists the way it was when al-Qaeda planned the 9/11 attacks in the Kandahar area, conducted the initial training for the attackers in training camps in Afghanistan before they moved on to Germany and then to U.S. flight schools"
About this Quote
Petraeus packs an entire war rationale into a single, breathless chain of logistics. The sentence moves like a staff briefing: sanctuary, planners, camps, Germany, flight schools. That procedural rhythm is the point. It turns a messy occupation into an intelligible supply line of terror, suggesting that U.S. presence is less a choice than an interruption in an enemy’s pipeline. Afghanistan becomes not a country but an infrastructure risk.
The specific intent is defensive and preemptive: justify continued engagement by anchoring it to the clearest American trauma available, 9/11, and by framing withdrawal as a rewind button. “Once again” does heavy lifting, implying history’s default setting is Afghanistan-as-base unless the U.S. actively prevents it. Petraeus is also careful with the vocabulary of professionalism: “sanctuary” sounds strategic rather than vengeful; “transnational extremists” is broad enough to cover shifting targets without naming today’s insurgent, tomorrow’s franchise.
The subtext is political triage. By tracing the attackers’ journey through Germany and U.S. flight schools, he quietly spreads responsibility across borders and bureaucracies, but keeps Afghanistan as the crucial origin point. It’s a narrative designed for skeptics: not nation-building, not democracy promotion, just threat management.
Context matters: spoken in an era when the war’s aims were contested and patience was thin, this is a commander’s attempt to reattach an expensive, ambiguous mission to a single, morally unassailable memory. The argument isn’t that victory is near; it’s that forgetting is dangerous.
The specific intent is defensive and preemptive: justify continued engagement by anchoring it to the clearest American trauma available, 9/11, and by framing withdrawal as a rewind button. “Once again” does heavy lifting, implying history’s default setting is Afghanistan-as-base unless the U.S. actively prevents it. Petraeus is also careful with the vocabulary of professionalism: “sanctuary” sounds strategic rather than vengeful; “transnational extremists” is broad enough to cover shifting targets without naming today’s insurgent, tomorrow’s franchise.
The subtext is political triage. By tracing the attackers’ journey through Germany and U.S. flight schools, he quietly spreads responsibility across borders and bureaucracies, but keeps Afghanistan as the crucial origin point. It’s a narrative designed for skeptics: not nation-building, not democracy promotion, just threat management.
Context matters: spoken in an era when the war’s aims were contested and patience was thin, this is a commander’s attempt to reattach an expensive, ambiguous mission to a single, morally unassailable memory. The argument isn’t that victory is near; it’s that forgetting is dangerous.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by David
Add to List






