"We've got to recognize that when we march into Iraq, we're setting up the card tables in front of every university in the Arab world, the Islamic world, to recruit for al-Qaida"
About this Quote
Matthews frames the Iraq invasion less as a battlefield gamble than as a marketing campaign for the enemy. The “card tables” image is the killer move: banal, campus-normal, almost laughably mundane. He strips terrorism of its mystique and recasts recruitment as something you can do with flyers and a sign-up sheet. That’s not softening al-Qaida; it’s an indictment of American strategy as spectacularly enabling. War, in this view, doesn’t just “create instability” in the abstract. It manufactures a social scene where radicalization becomes a plausible extracurricular.
The line also sneaks in a rebuke of post-9/11 political storytelling. The selling point of Iraq was preemption and safety; Matthews flips it into blowback logic: the very act meant to deter becomes the engine of future threats. “When we march” implicates the collective, not just policymakers, and it does so in the language of inevitability. Marching is what empires do when they’ve convinced themselves history is on their side. The subtext: you can’t bomb your way out of a legitimacy crisis.
Context matters: early-2000s cable news rewarded certainty and patriotism, while dissent was often treated as disloyalty. Matthews, a mainstream TV political voice, isn’t offering a moral lament so much as a pragmatic warning in the idiom of American politics: you are about to make your opponent’s recruiting easier, younger, smarter, and angrier. The sentence is built to puncture confidence, not to win a seminar.
The line also sneaks in a rebuke of post-9/11 political storytelling. The selling point of Iraq was preemption and safety; Matthews flips it into blowback logic: the very act meant to deter becomes the engine of future threats. “When we march” implicates the collective, not just policymakers, and it does so in the language of inevitability. Marching is what empires do when they’ve convinced themselves history is on their side. The subtext: you can’t bomb your way out of a legitimacy crisis.
Context matters: early-2000s cable news rewarded certainty and patriotism, while dissent was often treated as disloyalty. Matthews, a mainstream TV political voice, isn’t offering a moral lament so much as a pragmatic warning in the idiom of American politics: you are about to make your opponent’s recruiting easier, younger, smarter, and angrier. The sentence is built to puncture confidence, not to win a seminar.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Chris
Add to List


