"What an insignificant life is this which I am now leading!"
About this Quote
Self-reproach, sharpened into theater: Boswell’s line lands like a groan overheard in a mirror-lined hallway. “What an insignificant life” isn’t a measured diagnosis; it’s a performance of conscience, the kind that turns private dissatisfaction into a sentence built to be reread. The wording matters. “This which I am now leading” narrows the scope to the present tense, implying he knows other versions of himself are possible and, worse, once felt imminent. Insignificance here isn’t poverty or obscurity so much as a failure of narrative: a life not adding up to the story he believes he should be living.
Context is everything with Boswell: the lawyer who wanted to be a man of letters, the social climber who became history’s most famous note-taker, the bundle of appetites who kept auditing his own soul. In an 18th-century culture obsessed with improvement, reputation, and the moral bookkeeping of diaries, this lament reads like a symptom of ambition colliding with inertia. He’s not confessing to having no gifts; he’s accusing himself of squandering them.
The subtext is a peculiar kind of vanity: the fear of being ordinary, dressed up as humility. Boswell’s genius was to turn that anxious self-surveillance into literature. The irony is that “insignificant” is exactly the wrong word for a man whose compulsive self-flagellation produced one of the era’s great records of personality. His despair works because it’s both sincere and strategic: an emotional jolt meant to provoke reform, and a line crafted to make his inner crisis feel consequential.
Context is everything with Boswell: the lawyer who wanted to be a man of letters, the social climber who became history’s most famous note-taker, the bundle of appetites who kept auditing his own soul. In an 18th-century culture obsessed with improvement, reputation, and the moral bookkeeping of diaries, this lament reads like a symptom of ambition colliding with inertia. He’s not confessing to having no gifts; he’s accusing himself of squandering them.
The subtext is a peculiar kind of vanity: the fear of being ordinary, dressed up as humility. Boswell’s genius was to turn that anxious self-surveillance into literature. The irony is that “insignificant” is exactly the wrong word for a man whose compulsive self-flagellation produced one of the era’s great records of personality. His despair works because it’s both sincere and strategic: an emotional jolt meant to provoke reform, and a line crafted to make his inner crisis feel consequential.
Quote Details
| Topic | Meaning of Life |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List
