"What another would have done as well as you, do not do it. What another would have said as well as you, do not say it; what another would have written as well, do not write it. Be faithful to that which exists nowhere but in yourself-and thus make yourself indispensable"
About this Quote
Gide’s advice cuts with the cold clarity of a novelist who knows how quickly “talent” becomes indistinguishable from competence. He isn’t praising originality as a cute aesthetic; he’s issuing a practical warning about replaceability. If someone else can do it “as well as you,” your labor is just labor. Your voice becomes a commodity, your craft a service, your presence negotiable.
The line works because it weaponizes comparison. Gide doesn’t say “be yourself” in the soft, therapeutic register we’re used to. He draws a harsher boundary: don’t waste your finite time producing work that could have been produced by any adequately trained person. The subtext is almost Calvinist in its discipline: artistic life is an economy, and the only defensible currency is the part of you that cannot be swapped out. “Indispensable” is the key word; it drags the romantic myth of authenticity into the realm of survival and power.
Context matters. Gide wrote in a period when the modernist project was forcing literature to justify itself against the rise of mass culture, journalism, and industrial production. The anxiety wasn’t simply “How do I express myself?” but “How do I avoid becoming a unit?” His own career - restless, formally adventurous, morally unorthodox - reads like an extended experiment in refusing the generic self.
Still, Gide’s command contains a trap: if taken literally, it can turn art into a purity test. The better reading is strategic. Learn the common moves, then refuse to be satisfied with them. Fidelity to “that which exists nowhere but in yourself” isn’t narcissism; it’s a refusal to let the world’s templates do your living for you.
The line works because it weaponizes comparison. Gide doesn’t say “be yourself” in the soft, therapeutic register we’re used to. He draws a harsher boundary: don’t waste your finite time producing work that could have been produced by any adequately trained person. The subtext is almost Calvinist in its discipline: artistic life is an economy, and the only defensible currency is the part of you that cannot be swapped out. “Indispensable” is the key word; it drags the romantic myth of authenticity into the realm of survival and power.
Context matters. Gide wrote in a period when the modernist project was forcing literature to justify itself against the rise of mass culture, journalism, and industrial production. The anxiety wasn’t simply “How do I express myself?” but “How do I avoid becoming a unit?” His own career - restless, formally adventurous, morally unorthodox - reads like an extended experiment in refusing the generic self.
Still, Gide’s command contains a trap: if taken literally, it can turn art into a purity test. The better reading is strategic. Learn the common moves, then refuse to be satisfied with them. Fidelity to “that which exists nowhere but in yourself” isn’t narcissism; it’s a refusal to let the world’s templates do your living for you.
Quote Details
| Topic | Self-Improvement |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Andre
Add to List
