"What does immortality mean to me? That we all want more time; and we want it to be quality time"
About this Quote
Immortality, in Joan D. Vinge's framing, gets stripped of its sci-fi chrome and left as a brutally practical craving: not forever, but enough. The opening question sounds like it’s teeing up grand metaphysics, yet she answers with the language of calendars and lived experience. That bait-and-switch is the point. Vinge, a writer steeped in speculative futures, treats eternity less as a technological prize than as a human negotiation with scarcity.
The intent is corrective. Immortality is often sold as an upgrade to the self; Vinge recasts it as an indictment of the present. If “we all want more time,” it implies the time we have is routinely stolen, wasted, or thinned out by work, illness, obligation, anxiety. The subtext isn’t “death is bad,” it’s “life as organized doesn’t feel like it belongs to us.” Her second clause tightens the screw: “quality time” is the phrase people use when they’re already losing a battle with the clock. It’s a domestic term, almost corporate in its familiarity, and that mundanity undercuts the fantasy of immortality. Even infinite years would be hollow if they’re filled with the same depleted hours.
Context matters: Vinge comes out of late-20th-century science fiction, a tradition obsessed with life extension, cybernetics, and posthuman escape hatches. She’s reminding us that the oldest wish in the genre is also the simplest: not to live forever, but to live better before the end arrives.
The intent is corrective. Immortality is often sold as an upgrade to the self; Vinge recasts it as an indictment of the present. If “we all want more time,” it implies the time we have is routinely stolen, wasted, or thinned out by work, illness, obligation, anxiety. The subtext isn’t “death is bad,” it’s “life as organized doesn’t feel like it belongs to us.” Her second clause tightens the screw: “quality time” is the phrase people use when they’re already losing a battle with the clock. It’s a domestic term, almost corporate in its familiarity, and that mundanity undercuts the fantasy of immortality. Even infinite years would be hollow if they’re filled with the same depleted hours.
Context matters: Vinge comes out of late-20th-century science fiction, a tradition obsessed with life extension, cybernetics, and posthuman escape hatches. She’s reminding us that the oldest wish in the genre is also the simplest: not to live forever, but to live better before the end arrives.
Quote Details
| Topic | Time |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Joan
Add to List







