"What I said about John was that he liberated me from my anxieties about writing in a correct, acceptable way"
About this Quote
Liberation is a loaded word for a writer like Harry Mathews: it implies a jailer, a set of rules so internalized they feel like morality. When he credits "John" with freeing him from the need to write "in a correct, acceptable way", he is really describing an escape from a whole ecosystem of literary gatekeeping: workshops, reviewers, polite expectations of coherence, taste, and decorum. "Correct" and "acceptable" aren’t just stylistic adjectives here; they’re social verbs, the quiet commands issued by institutions that reward legibility and punish risk.
Mathews, associated with Oulipo and its devotion to constraint, makes the line slyly paradoxical. He’s not rejecting form; he’s rejecting compliance. The subtext is that anxiety doesn’t come from difficulty but from permission: the fear that the work must justify itself to an imagined panel of reasonable people. "John" (very likely John Ashbery, a poet whose charisma and formal freedom changed what could pass as serious American writing) becomes less a mentor than a proof-of-concept. If someone can write past conventional sense-making and still be celebrated, then the border patrol was never inevitable.
The sentence also performs its own thesis. It’s conversational, indirect, almost modest, but it smuggles a radical aesthetic claim: art doesn’t mature by perfecting acceptability; it matures by unlearning the need for it. Mathews frames influence not as imitation, but as a recalibration of fear.
Mathews, associated with Oulipo and its devotion to constraint, makes the line slyly paradoxical. He’s not rejecting form; he’s rejecting compliance. The subtext is that anxiety doesn’t come from difficulty but from permission: the fear that the work must justify itself to an imagined panel of reasonable people. "John" (very likely John Ashbery, a poet whose charisma and formal freedom changed what could pass as serious American writing) becomes less a mentor than a proof-of-concept. If someone can write past conventional sense-making and still be celebrated, then the border patrol was never inevitable.
The sentence also performs its own thesis. It’s conversational, indirect, almost modest, but it smuggles a radical aesthetic claim: art doesn’t mature by perfecting acceptability; it matures by unlearning the need for it. Mathews frames influence not as imitation, but as a recalibration of fear.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Harry
Add to List
