"What I think is that Fox has done a very smart job of carving out their place"
About this Quote
Brokaw’s compliment lands like an observation, but it plays as a diagnosis. Calling Fox “very smart” isn’t moral approval; it’s professional recognition of an audience strategy that worked. He’s describing a network not as a newsroom but as a brand that found market fit, then defended it aggressively. The phrase “carving out their place” is the tell: it suggests territory, competition, and permanent boundaries, not a shared civic mission. In Brokaw’s old-school broadcast universe, “place” used to mean a relatively common set of facts delivered in a neutral tone. Here it means a lane.
The intent is careful: praise the tactics without litigating the consequences. That restraint is classic Brokaw. As a mainstream news elder, he can’t easily say “Fox weaponized identity and grievance” without sounding partisan, so he reaches for the language of business success and positioning. It’s a journalist’s sidestep that still communicates plenty to anyone fluent in media economics.
The subtext is that Fox’s achievement wasn’t simply better reporting; it was creating a reliable relationship with viewers by validating a worldview, offering consistency, and turning “we’re not them” into a product feature. “Smart” also implies others were slow, complacent, or trapped by older norms of objectivity while Fox built a tighter feedback loop between politics, entertainment, and loyalty.
Context matters: Brokaw came up when three networks shaped the national conversation. His line reads like someone watching that era collapse into niche empires and admitting, with a mix of admiration and unease, that Fox understood the new rules first.
The intent is careful: praise the tactics without litigating the consequences. That restraint is classic Brokaw. As a mainstream news elder, he can’t easily say “Fox weaponized identity and grievance” without sounding partisan, so he reaches for the language of business success and positioning. It’s a journalist’s sidestep that still communicates plenty to anyone fluent in media economics.
The subtext is that Fox’s achievement wasn’t simply better reporting; it was creating a reliable relationship with viewers by validating a worldview, offering consistency, and turning “we’re not them” into a product feature. “Smart” also implies others were slow, complacent, or trapped by older norms of objectivity while Fox built a tighter feedback loop between politics, entertainment, and loyalty.
Context matters: Brokaw came up when three networks shaped the national conversation. His line reads like someone watching that era collapse into niche empires and admitting, with a mix of admiration and unease, that Fox understood the new rules first.
Quote Details
| Topic | Vision & Strategy |
|---|
More Quotes by Tom
Add to List


