"What is a good performance? It lies in the hands and head of a performer... the shortest way between two people is not a straight line"
About this Quote
A “good performance,” for Earle Brown, isn’t a museum-grade reproduction; it’s a live negotiation between intention and encounter. As a composer who helped define mid-century experimental music (and flirted openly with indeterminacy), Brown is pushing back on the old hierarchy where the score is sovereign and the performer is a well-trained delivery system. His phrasing relocates authorship: the piece is not fully “in” the notation but distributed across the performer’s hands (technique, touch, timing) and head (judgment, risk tolerance, imagination). That division matters because it frames performance as cognition, not just execution.
“The shortest way between two people is not a straight line” is the sly hinge. It borrows the certainty of geometry and then denies it, arguing that human connection happens through detours: hesitation, color, breath, rubato, even mistake. In Brown’s world, the most direct communication may be asymmetrical and improvised, because listeners don’t bond with correctness; they bond with presence. The subtext is almost democratic: the performer isn’t a servant of the composer, and the audience isn’t a passive receiver. A good performance is a social event where meaning is made in real time.
Contextually, this reads like an aesthetic manifesto from the postwar avant-garde: skepticism toward fixed authority, appetite for contingency, a belief that form can emerge from interaction. Brown’s line insists that intimacy in music isn’t achieved by the straight line of obedience, but by the curved, human path of interpretation.
“The shortest way between two people is not a straight line” is the sly hinge. It borrows the certainty of geometry and then denies it, arguing that human connection happens through detours: hesitation, color, breath, rubato, even mistake. In Brown’s world, the most direct communication may be asymmetrical and improvised, because listeners don’t bond with correctness; they bond with presence. The subtext is almost democratic: the performer isn’t a servant of the composer, and the audience isn’t a passive receiver. A good performance is a social event where meaning is made in real time.
Contextually, this reads like an aesthetic manifesto from the postwar avant-garde: skepticism toward fixed authority, appetite for contingency, a belief that form can emerge from interaction. Brown’s line insists that intimacy in music isn’t achieved by the straight line of obedience, but by the curved, human path of interpretation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Earle
Add to List




