"What is the use being a big man if you are wrong?"
About this Quote
A novelist’s jab dressed up as a plainspoken question, Dos Passos’s line punctures the oldest American delusion: that scale confers legitimacy. “Big man” isn’t just physical size or public stature; it’s the whole swaggering ecosystem of bosses, magnates, generals, and self-mythologizers who expect their prominence to stand in for being right. By framing it as “use,” he drags authority down to the level of practical value. If power can’t even purchase truth, what exactly is it for besides intimidation?
The brilliance is in the moral economics. “Being” a big man is treated like a job you might quit if the returns aren’t there. That’s the Dos Passos sensibility: suspicious of the machinery of prestige, allergic to the way institutions and celebrity turn error into policy. The sentence has the cadence of a heckler in a town hall, not a philosopher in a seminar, and that populist edge matters. It implies that “wrong” isn’t a private mistake; it’s a public cost, paid by everyone beneath the big man’s shadow.
Context helps. Dos Passos came up with the Left, chronicled America’s industrial churn, then famously soured on ideological pageantry and strong-man certainty as the 20th century supplied both in bulk. The line reads like a compact anti-fascist (and anti-elitist) immune response: your résumé doesn’t absolve your reality-testing. In a culture that confuses visibility with verdict, it’s a scalpel of a question.
The brilliance is in the moral economics. “Being” a big man is treated like a job you might quit if the returns aren’t there. That’s the Dos Passos sensibility: suspicious of the machinery of prestige, allergic to the way institutions and celebrity turn error into policy. The sentence has the cadence of a heckler in a town hall, not a philosopher in a seminar, and that populist edge matters. It implies that “wrong” isn’t a private mistake; it’s a public cost, paid by everyone beneath the big man’s shadow.
Context helps. Dos Passos came up with the Left, chronicled America’s industrial churn, then famously soured on ideological pageantry and strong-man certainty as the 20th century supplied both in bulk. The line reads like a compact anti-fascist (and anti-elitist) immune response: your résumé doesn’t absolve your reality-testing. In a culture that confuses visibility with verdict, it’s a scalpel of a question.
Quote Details
| Topic | Humility |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List








