"What is thine is mine, and all mine is thine"
About this Quote
A line like "What is thine is mine, and all mine is thine" sounds like pure intimacy, almost a vow. Coming from Cicero, it’s less moonlight and more architecture: a compact formula for how Romans wanted solidarity to work, whether in friendship, household, or republic. The chiasmus (thine/mine; mine/thine) is doing the heavy lifting. It turns reciprocity into symmetry, making exchange feel natural and inevitable rather than negotiated. That’s the rhetorical trick: it erases the awkward middle step where people tally debts.
Cicero’s larger project, especially in his writing on friendship and duty, is to rescue social trust from corruption, faction, and self-interest. Late Republican Rome was a world of patronage networks, land grabs, and political alliances that were transactional even when dressed up as virtue. This sentence offers a moral counterspell: the ideal bond is one where property boundaries soften because character boundaries harden. If both parties are genuinely upright, shared goods won’t become a loophole for exploitation.
The subtext is defensive. Only a culture saturated in opportunism needs to insist so brightly that mutual belonging is possible. Read one way, it’s an ethical standard: friendship means treating another’s welfare as your own. Read another, it’s a warning label: the language of total sharing is exactly what con men, demagogues, and bad friends borrow to justify taking. Cicero’s intent is aspirational, but he knows how easily noble reciprocity becomes a mask for theft.
Cicero’s larger project, especially in his writing on friendship and duty, is to rescue social trust from corruption, faction, and self-interest. Late Republican Rome was a world of patronage networks, land grabs, and political alliances that were transactional even when dressed up as virtue. This sentence offers a moral counterspell: the ideal bond is one where property boundaries soften because character boundaries harden. If both parties are genuinely upright, shared goods won’t become a loophole for exploitation.
The subtext is defensive. Only a culture saturated in opportunism needs to insist so brightly that mutual belonging is possible. Read one way, it’s an ethical standard: friendship means treating another’s welfare as your own. Read another, it’s a warning label: the language of total sharing is exactly what con men, demagogues, and bad friends borrow to justify taking. Cicero’s intent is aspirational, but he knows how easily noble reciprocity becomes a mask for theft.
Quote Details
| Topic | Romantic |
|---|
More Quotes by Cicero
Add to List
