"What is truth? said jesting Pilate; and would not stay for an answer"
About this Quote
Pilate’s line lands like a thrown dagger: not because the question is deep, but because he won’t wait for the reply. Bacon, the great advocate of inquiry and method, isn’t admiring skepticism here; he’s diagnosing a fashionable, corrosive pose. “Jesting” matters. Pilate isn’t a tormented seeker. He’s the kind of powerful man who treats truth as a parlor problem, a clever abstraction you toss off to show you’re above earnestness. Then he exits. The real sin isn’t doubt. It’s impatience.
Bacon lifts the moment from the Gospel of John, but he uses it as a mirror for his own age: a late Renaissance culture drunk on rhetoric, courtly performance, and religious fracture, where “truth” was a dangerous word and cynicism could read as sophistication. Pilate becomes the prototype of the elite relativist: someone who intuits that truth has consequences, then dodges them. The subtext is political as much as philosophical. If truth is always debatable, then accountability is always postponable.
That final clause, “and would not stay for an answer,” is Bacon’s quiet indictment. It’s not that answers don’t exist; it’s that institutions of power often can’t afford to hear them. Bacon’s broader project (in essays like “Of Truth”) insists that knowledge requires discipline, not vibes: patience, procedure, a willingness to be corrected. Pilate’s joke is a warning about what happens when wit becomes a shield against responsibility.
Bacon lifts the moment from the Gospel of John, but he uses it as a mirror for his own age: a late Renaissance culture drunk on rhetoric, courtly performance, and religious fracture, where “truth” was a dangerous word and cynicism could read as sophistication. Pilate becomes the prototype of the elite relativist: someone who intuits that truth has consequences, then dodges them. The subtext is political as much as philosophical. If truth is always debatable, then accountability is always postponable.
That final clause, “and would not stay for an answer,” is Bacon’s quiet indictment. It’s not that answers don’t exist; it’s that institutions of power often can’t afford to hear them. Bacon’s broader project (in essays like “Of Truth”) insists that knowledge requires discipline, not vibes: patience, procedure, a willingness to be corrected. Pilate’s joke is a warning about what happens when wit becomes a shield against responsibility.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Francis Bacon, "Of Truth", essay in Essays (1625). Opening line: "What is truth? said jesting Pilate; and would not stay for an answer." |
More Quotes by Francis
Add to List






