"What we gave, we have; What we spent, we had; What we left, we lost"
About this Quote
Tryon Edwards compresses a whole Protestant moral economy into three clean clauses, each one a little verdict. The line reads like bookkeeping, but it’s really an argument about time, death, and the delusions of possession. By pairing “gave,” “spent,” and “left” with “have,” “had,” and “lost,” he makes ownership feel provisional: the only wealth you can truly claim is what you convert into either generosity or lived experience. Everything else is inventory waiting to be mislaid.
The cleverness is in the tense shifts. “What we gave, we have” flips the expected math. Charity becomes the only durable asset, not because it literally returns dividends, but because it consolidates meaning: it survives as memory, reputation, moral self-concept, and (in Edwards’s theological frame) eternal account. “What we spent, we had” grants a limited dignity to enjoyment, but cages it in the past tense. Pleasure is real, not sinful, yet it doesn’t last. Then the guillotine: “What we left, we lost.” The language is blunt enough to sting anyone practicing polite thrift. In a culture where “leaving something behind” is treated as virtue and legacy, Edwards points out the loophole: what you hoard becomes someone else’s story, or nobody’s.
Context matters. As a 19th-century theologian speaking to an America swelling with commerce and middle-class aspiration, Edwards isn’t condemning wealth so much as disciplining it. He’s offering a spiritual corrective to accumulation: convert surplus into giving, convert life into use, because death will audit the rest.
The cleverness is in the tense shifts. “What we gave, we have” flips the expected math. Charity becomes the only durable asset, not because it literally returns dividends, but because it consolidates meaning: it survives as memory, reputation, moral self-concept, and (in Edwards’s theological frame) eternal account. “What we spent, we had” grants a limited dignity to enjoyment, but cages it in the past tense. Pleasure is real, not sinful, yet it doesn’t last. Then the guillotine: “What we left, we lost.” The language is blunt enough to sting anyone practicing polite thrift. In a culture where “leaving something behind” is treated as virtue and legacy, Edwards points out the loophole: what you hoard becomes someone else’s story, or nobody’s.
Context matters. As a 19th-century theologian speaking to an America swelling with commerce and middle-class aspiration, Edwards isn’t condemning wealth so much as disciplining it. He’s offering a spiritual corrective to accumulation: convert surplus into giving, convert life into use, because death will audit the rest.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Tryon
Add to List










