"What we were seeing was a little bit like throwing the apple up in the air and seeing it blast off into space"
About this Quote
You can hear the scientist’s bafflement straining against his own training. Saul Perlmutter reaches for the most childlike physics demo imaginable - toss an apple, watch it fall - and then breaks it on purpose: the apple doesn’t drop, it rockets away. The intent isn’t poetic flourish so much as an emergency metaphor, a way to translate a cosmological shock into a picture your nervous system understands. Gravity is supposed to be the dependable punchline. If the apple “blasts off,” something foundational has flipped.
That’s the subtext of Perlmutter’s line: the data weren’t merely surprising; they were insolent. His team’s supernova measurements in the late 1990s implied the universe’s expansion is accelerating, not slowing down under gravity’s pull. The apple is the classical expectation (attraction), the blast-off is dark energy’s rude entrance (repulsion or, more precisely, a negative-pressure component of spacetime). He’s describing the moment when the math stops feeling like math and starts feeling like a prank played on your intuitions.
The context matters because this wasn’t an armchair provocation. It came from painstaking observational cosmology: standard candles, error bars, calibration anxiety, the dread of systematic mistakes. That’s why the metaphor lands. It performs humility and confidence at once: humility that even experts need simple images to admit disbelief, confidence that the evidence was strong enough to warrant saying something that sounds, at first blush, impossible. It’s the sound of a paradigm shift getting domesticated into a sentence.
That’s the subtext of Perlmutter’s line: the data weren’t merely surprising; they were insolent. His team’s supernova measurements in the late 1990s implied the universe’s expansion is accelerating, not slowing down under gravity’s pull. The apple is the classical expectation (attraction), the blast-off is dark energy’s rude entrance (repulsion or, more precisely, a negative-pressure component of spacetime). He’s describing the moment when the math stops feeling like math and starts feeling like a prank played on your intuitions.
The context matters because this wasn’t an armchair provocation. It came from painstaking observational cosmology: standard candles, error bars, calibration anxiety, the dread of systematic mistakes. That’s why the metaphor lands. It performs humility and confidence at once: humility that even experts need simple images to admit disbelief, confidence that the evidence was strong enough to warrant saying something that sounds, at first blush, impossible. It’s the sound of a paradigm shift getting domesticated into a sentence.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|
More Quotes by Saul
Add to List






