"Whatever extra there is in me at any given moment isn't fully formed. I am hardly aware of it; it awaits the next book. It will - with luck - come to me during the actual writing, and it will take me by surprise"
About this Quote
Naipaul frames creativity less as a vault of inner riches than as a stubborn blankness that only the act of writing can disturb. The phrase "whatever extra there is in me" is doing double duty: it concedes the romantic idea of an inner surplus, then immediately demystifies it. This "extra" is not a stable essence, not a personality trait you can brand and sell. It's unformed, almost inaccessible, and Naipaul presents himself as its baffled custodian.
The subtext is both modest and controlling. Modest because he denies full self-knowledge; controlling because he relocates revelation to the page, where he has authority. In a culture that treats writers as people who "have stories", Naipaul insists that stories are not possessions but events. They happen under pressure, "during the actual writing", when the mind is forced to build meaning out of uncertainty. That insistence also protects him from the expectation of constant wisdom: if he doesn't yet know what the work will yield, he can't be pre-judged for not already being there.
Context matters: Naipaul's career is marked by a forensic, sometimes unsparing gaze at postcolonial societies and at his own dislocations. "With luck" nods to the contingency beneath the craft, a gambler's realism from a writer who knew talent isn't the same as control. The best line is the last: surprise. Not inspiration-as-thunderbolt, but discovery-as-consequence, the shock of meeting a self you can only access through the discipline you thought you were merely practicing.
The subtext is both modest and controlling. Modest because he denies full self-knowledge; controlling because he relocates revelation to the page, where he has authority. In a culture that treats writers as people who "have stories", Naipaul insists that stories are not possessions but events. They happen under pressure, "during the actual writing", when the mind is forced to build meaning out of uncertainty. That insistence also protects him from the expectation of constant wisdom: if he doesn't yet know what the work will yield, he can't be pre-judged for not already being there.
Context matters: Naipaul's career is marked by a forensic, sometimes unsparing gaze at postcolonial societies and at his own dislocations. "With luck" nods to the contingency beneath the craft, a gambler's realism from a writer who knew talent isn't the same as control. The best line is the last: surprise. Not inspiration-as-thunderbolt, but discovery-as-consequence, the shock of meeting a self you can only access through the discipline you thought you were merely practicing.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by S. Naipaul
Add to List
