"Whatever is funny is subversive, every joke is ultimately a custard pie... a dirty joke is a sort of mental rebellion"
About this Quote
Comedy, for Orwell, is never just relief; it is a small act of sabotage. The line works because it refuses to let humor stay innocent. Calling every joke “ultimately a custard pie” drags wit down from the salon to the slapstick stage, insisting that even the most refined satire ends in indignity: someone, somewhere, gets metaphorically splattered. That image is doing quiet political work. A custard pie is childish, bodily, and unrespectable, which is precisely why it punctures authority. Power depends on people maintaining the right face at the right time.
Orwell’s phrasing also smuggles in a hard truth about censorship and propriety. “Dirty joke” isn’t just about sex; it’s about what polite society marks as unfit for public speech. When he calls it “mental rebellion,” he’s pointing at the pleasure of thinking thoughts you’re not supposed to think, and saying them in a form that slips past the guards. The joke’s alibi is its own unseriousness: it can always claim it “didn’t mean anything,” even as it rearranges what can be safely mocked.
The context is Orwell’s lifelong suspicion of enforced dignity, whether from the state, the class system, or ideological movements that demand reverence. After the propaganda and mass mobilization of the 1930s and 40s, he understood how easily language becomes a uniform. Humor is one of the few ways the private mind can wrinkle that uniform without immediately getting arrested. Subversion, here, isn’t a revolution; it’s the stubborn refusal to stay solemn on command.
Orwell’s phrasing also smuggles in a hard truth about censorship and propriety. “Dirty joke” isn’t just about sex; it’s about what polite society marks as unfit for public speech. When he calls it “mental rebellion,” he’s pointing at the pleasure of thinking thoughts you’re not supposed to think, and saying them in a form that slips past the guards. The joke’s alibi is its own unseriousness: it can always claim it “didn’t mean anything,” even as it rearranges what can be safely mocked.
The context is Orwell’s lifelong suspicion of enforced dignity, whether from the state, the class system, or ideological movements that demand reverence. After the propaganda and mass mobilization of the 1930s and 40s, he understood how easily language becomes a uniform. Humor is one of the few ways the private mind can wrinkle that uniform without immediately getting arrested. Subversion, here, isn’t a revolution; it’s the stubborn refusal to stay solemn on command.
Quote Details
| Topic | Funny |
|---|
More Quotes by George
Add to List





