"When a Benefit is wrongly conferred, the author of the Benefit may often be said to injure"
About this Quote
A misdirected good deed can land like an insult. Plato’s line is cold-eyed about the moral vanity baked into “helping”: the giver may feel righteous, but the recipient pays the price when the gift is ill-judged, undeserved, or structurally corrupting. The sting is in “wrongly conferred.” This isn’t a complaint about generosity; it’s an accusation that benefits, distributed without wisdom, become a kind of violence.
The subtext is thoroughly Platonic: benefits are not neutral objects you pass around like coins. They shape character. Give power, praise, money, or status to someone unfit for it, and you don’t merely make a mistake - you manufacture vice. You teach entitlement, dependency, or impunity. You also injure the community by rewarding the wrong signals: flattery over truth, ambition over competence, loyalty over justice. In Plato’s world, that’s how a polis rots: not only through obvious injustice, but through sentimental or self-interested “kindness” that dodges the harder question of what someone actually needs to become better.
Contextually, this sits inside Plato’s larger war on appearances and soft moral bookkeeping. He distrusts acts that look benevolent but evade rational calibration. The line also throws shade at the giver: if your benefit “injures,” your intent was never the whole story. Either you didn’t know enough to help, or you wanted the glow of being seen as helpful. Plato’s real target is moral theater - the charity that comforts the benefactor while quietly deforming its subject.
The subtext is thoroughly Platonic: benefits are not neutral objects you pass around like coins. They shape character. Give power, praise, money, or status to someone unfit for it, and you don’t merely make a mistake - you manufacture vice. You teach entitlement, dependency, or impunity. You also injure the community by rewarding the wrong signals: flattery over truth, ambition over competence, loyalty over justice. In Plato’s world, that’s how a polis rots: not only through obvious injustice, but through sentimental or self-interested “kindness” that dodges the harder question of what someone actually needs to become better.
Contextually, this sits inside Plato’s larger war on appearances and soft moral bookkeeping. He distrusts acts that look benevolent but evade rational calibration. The line also throws shade at the giver: if your benefit “injures,” your intent was never the whole story. Either you didn’t know enough to help, or you wanted the glow of being seen as helpful. Plato’s real target is moral theater - the charity that comforts the benefactor while quietly deforming its subject.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Plato
Add to List
