Politics & Power Quote by Robert Smithson

"When a finished work of 20th century sculpture is placed in an 18th century garden, it is absorbed by the ideal representation of the past, thus reinforcing political and social values that are no longer with us"

Robert Smithson, Artist

About this Quote

Smithson is warning that the past doesn’t just “frame” modern art; it domesticates it. Drop a jagged, postwar sculpture into an 18th-century garden - that aristocratic technology of nature, trimmed and curated to look effortlessly “ideal” - and the work is quietly drafted into a different story. The garden is already a political machine: it stages harmony as hierarchy, beauty as ownership, landscape as a symbol of control. In that setting, even a confrontational modern object can start reading like a tasteful accent, a certified heirloom of culture rather than a challenge to it.

The line “absorbed by the ideal representation of the past” is doing the heavy lifting. Smithson isn’t attacking the sculpture’s form so much as the environment’s power to edit meaning. Site becomes ideology. The garden offers a ready-made script - nostalgia, refinement, continuity - that can neutralize the 20th century’s fractures: industrialization, war, alienation, mass politics. What was meant to be modern becomes a decorative footnote to a cultivated myth of permanence.

Context matters: Smithson, a key figure in Land Art, distrusted the museum’s ability to sanitize messy, entropic realities. His own work pushed outward into quarries, deserts, and industrial ruins - places that resist the soft-focus aura of “heritage.” Here he’s diagnosing a broader cultural habit: we use the past as an aesthetic filter, then mistake the filtered image for timeless truth. The result is political, not just visual: old values get smuggled back in under the cover of taste.

Quote Details

Topic	Art
Source	Help us find the source
Cite

More Quotes by Robert Add to List

About the Author

Robert Smithson (January 2, 1938 - July 20, 1973) was a Artist from USA.

32 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

"In the 19th century, you had bourgeois art without politics - an almost frozen idea of what beauty is"

Douglas Sirk, Director

"Painting and sculpture are very archaic forms. It's the only thing left in our industrial society where an individual alone can make something with not just his own hands, but brains, imagination, heart, maybe"

Philip Guston, Artist

"And the fifteenth century was an impassioned age, so ardent and serious in its pursuit of art that it consecrated everything with which art had to ad as a religious object"

Walter Pater, Critic

"The modern work of art, as I have said, is a symbol"

Herbert Read, Poet

"In a decaying society, art, if it is truthful, must also reflect decay. And unless it wants to break faith with its social function, art must show the world as changeable. And help to change it"

Ernst Fischer, Writer

"Of late years (perhaps as a result of our political changes), art has borrowed from history more than ever"

Alfred de Vigny, Poet

"At the beginning of the nineteenth century, we abandoned tradition, it's at that point that I intend to renew it because the present is built on the past just as the past was built on the times that went before it"

Adolf Loos, Architect

"The work of art shows people new directions and thinks of the future. The house thinks of the present"

Adolf Loos, Architect

"The craft of painting has virtually disappeared. There is hardly anyone left who really possesses it. For evidence one has only to look at the painters of this century"

Balthus, Artist

"Here society is reduced to its original elements, the whole fabric of art and conventionality is struck rudely to pieces, and men find themselves suddenly brought back to the wants and resources of their original natures"

Francis Parkman, Historian

"I think of art, at its most significant, as a DEW line, a Distant Early Warning system that can always be relied on to tell the old culture what is beginning to happen to it"

Marshall McLuhan, Sociologist

Marshall McLuhan

"The conventional notions of art have changed, and a lot of things done today are considered works of art that would have been rejected in the past"

David Rockefeller, Businessman

"Traditionally, art is to create and not to revive. To revive: leave that to the historians, who are looking backward"

Josef Albers, Artist

"And certainly the history of public sculpture has been disastrous, but that doesn't mean it ought not to continue, and the only way it even has a chance to continue is if the work gets out into the public"

Richard Serra, Sculptor

"Art cannot be modern. Art is primordially eternal"

Egon Schiele, Artist

"In its most limited sense, modern art would seem to concern itself only with the technical innovations of the period"

Edward Hopper, Artist

Edward Hopper

"The 1990s, after the reign of terror of academic vandalism, will be a decade of restoration: restoration of meaning, value, beauty, pleasure, and emotion to art and restoration of art to its audience"

Camille Paglia, Author

Camille Paglia

"The history of modern art is also the history of the progressive loss of art's audience. Art has increasingly become the concern of the artist and the bafflement of the public"

Paul Gauguin, Artist

Paul Gauguin

"We say to the British government: You have kept those sculptures for almost two centuries. You have cared for them as well as you could, for which we thank you. But now in the name of fairness and morality, please give them back"

Melina Mercouri, Actress

"Art need no longer be an account of past sensations. It can become the direct organization of more highly evolved sensations. It is a question of producing ourselves, not things that enslave us"

Angela Carter, Novelist

Angela Carter