"When a pianist sits down and does a virtuoso performance he is in a technical sense transmitting more information to a machine than any other human activity involving machinery allows"
About this Quote
Moog’s line flatters the pianist, but it’s really a love letter to the machine. He’s reframing virtuosity as data: ten fingers becoming a high-bandwidth interface, a human body effectively “programming” a complex system in real time. In the 1960s and 70s, when Moog helped turn room-sized electronic laboratories into playable instruments, that was the point. Synthesizers weren’t supposed to replace musicians; they were supposed to reward the same kind of tactile intelligence a great pianist already had.
The phrase “in a technical sense” does a lot of work. It’s a nerdy qualifier that quietly invites you to switch lenses, from romance to measurement. A virtuosic performance isn’t just expressive; it’s dense with control signals: timing, velocity, micro-dynamics, pedaling, articulation, the subtle deviations that make a phrase breathe. Moog is hinting that most “machinery” reduces humans to crude inputs - push button, pull lever, yes/no. The piano is the opposite: a centuries-old device that turns continuous nuance into sound with almost absurd sensitivity.
Subtextually, he’s making an argument about design ethics. The best machines don’t demand that people think like machines; they meet people at the level of embodied skill. For an inventor often associated with knobs, voltages, and patch cables, it’s also a provocative inversion: the pinnacle of “information transmission” isn’t a control room or cockpit, but an artist sweating over a keyboard, proving that precision and feeling can be the same gesture.
The phrase “in a technical sense” does a lot of work. It’s a nerdy qualifier that quietly invites you to switch lenses, from romance to measurement. A virtuosic performance isn’t just expressive; it’s dense with control signals: timing, velocity, micro-dynamics, pedaling, articulation, the subtle deviations that make a phrase breathe. Moog is hinting that most “machinery” reduces humans to crude inputs - push button, pull lever, yes/no. The piano is the opposite: a centuries-old device that turns continuous nuance into sound with almost absurd sensitivity.
Subtextually, he’s making an argument about design ethics. The best machines don’t demand that people think like machines; they meet people at the level of embodied skill. For an inventor often associated with knobs, voltages, and patch cables, it’s also a provocative inversion: the pinnacle of “information transmission” isn’t a control room or cockpit, but an artist sweating over a keyboard, proving that precision and feeling can be the same gesture.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List




