"When Delaware State University was founded in 1890, it was not by choice, but by social reality"
About this Quote
A politician’s neatest trick is to make inevitability sound like virtue, and Michael N. Castle does exactly that here. “Not by choice, but by social reality” is a sentence built to absolve: it shifts agency away from lawmakers and powerbrokers and onto an impersonal force field called “reality.” The phrase doesn’t accuse; it launder-facts. In a single clause, it acknowledges segregation without naming the people who enforced it.
The context is Delaware State University’s origin as a land-grant institution for Black students in the Jim Crow era, created because Black Delawareans were excluded from the state’s white land-grant college. Castle’s framing nods to that hard history while keeping the temperature low, a classic commemorative tone that fits dedications and anniversaries. It’s a way of saying, yes, the state did this, but also: don’t linger on blame.
The subtext is more complicated. By describing DSU’s founding as compelled, Castle elevates the institution’s resilience while quietly minimizing the moral ugliness that made it necessary. “Choice” implies a menu of options; “social reality” implies a closed system. That tension is the point: the line honors DSU’s birth as a product of constraint, and it asks listeners to read the school’s success as triumph over circumstance rather than as an ongoing indictment of policy.
It works rhetorically because it offers recognition without confrontation: a memory of exclusion translated into a palatable civic lesson about perseverance, not power.
The context is Delaware State University’s origin as a land-grant institution for Black students in the Jim Crow era, created because Black Delawareans were excluded from the state’s white land-grant college. Castle’s framing nods to that hard history while keeping the temperature low, a classic commemorative tone that fits dedications and anniversaries. It’s a way of saying, yes, the state did this, but also: don’t linger on blame.
The subtext is more complicated. By describing DSU’s founding as compelled, Castle elevates the institution’s resilience while quietly minimizing the moral ugliness that made it necessary. “Choice” implies a menu of options; “social reality” implies a closed system. That tension is the point: the line honors DSU’s birth as a product of constraint, and it asks listeners to read the school’s success as triumph over circumstance rather than as an ongoing indictment of policy.
It works rhetorically because it offers recognition without confrontation: a memory of exclusion translated into a palatable civic lesson about perseverance, not power.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by Michael
Add to List
