Skip to main content

Nature & Animals Quote by Barry Sonnenfeld

"When Frank the Pug is singing I Will Survive, the only reason it's funny is that Will is in that shot trying not to get angry. A shot of a dog singing I Will Survive on its own will not get a laugh"

About this Quote

Comedy isn`t an object; it`s a reaction shot. Barry Sonnenfeld is basically giving away the magician`s trick behind blockbuster laughs: the gag isn`t "a pug sings Gloria Gaynor". That`s novelty, a YouTube clip. The real engine is human strain in the frame, the visible effort to keep composure while chaos performs beside you. In Men in Black, Frank the Pug is an absurdist prop, but Will Smith`s simmering irritation is the metronome that makes the absurdity land. Without that grounded counterforce, the joke floats off into empty cute.

Sonnenfeld`s intent is practical, almost ruthless: laughter is engineered through contrast. A talking dog is already telling you it`s a joke; there`s no friction left. Put it next to a character with stakes and ego and a sense of decorum, and suddenly the dog is an intrusion, an insult to reality. Watching someone "trying not to get angry" invites the audience into a conspiratorial posture: we see the social rule being violated, and we enjoy the pressure building in the person who has to pretend it isn`t.

The subtext is also a quiet defense of craft against gimmick. Pop culture often mistakes "recognizable song + ironic performer" for comedy. Sonnenfeld argues for relational humor: the scene works because it captures a power dynamic (Frank performing; Will policing), an emotional truth (annoyance you can feel), and a rhythm of restraint that makes the eventual release satisfying. The dog is garnish. The human reaction is the meal.

Quote Details

TopicMovie
SourceHelp us find the source
Cite

Citation Formats

APA Style (7th ed.)
Sonnenfeld, Barry. (2026, January 16). When Frank the Pug is singing I Will Survive, the only reason it's funny is that Will is in that shot trying not to get angry. A shot of a dog singing I Will Survive on its own will not get a laugh. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/when-frank-the-pug-is-singing-i-will-survive-the-123185/

Chicago Style
Sonnenfeld, Barry. "When Frank the Pug is singing I Will Survive, the only reason it's funny is that Will is in that shot trying not to get angry. A shot of a dog singing I Will Survive on its own will not get a laugh." FixQuotes. January 16, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/when-frank-the-pug-is-singing-i-will-survive-the-123185/.

MLA Style (9th ed.)
"When Frank the Pug is singing I Will Survive, the only reason it's funny is that Will is in that shot trying not to get angry. A shot of a dog singing I Will Survive on its own will not get a laugh." FixQuotes, 16 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/when-frank-the-pug-is-singing-i-will-survive-the-123185/. Accessed 12 Feb. 2026.

More Quotes by Barry Add to List
Reaction Shots and the Mechanics of Screen Comedy
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

USA Flag

Barry Sonnenfeld (born April 1, 1953) is a Producer from USA.

14 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

Jeanne Calment, Celebrity
Indra Devi, Celebrity
Claudette Colbert, Actress
Henri Bergson, Philosopher
Jack Benny, Comedian
Jack Benny