"When I finally gave up any hope of doing anything representative of the American family, I actually seemed to have tapped into other people's weirdness in that way"
About this Quote
The irony here is that Franzen only reaches something like “the American family” by quitting the job description. The line reads like a confession from a novelist who’s been burned by the national allegory business: the moment you aim for “representative,” you start sanding down the very abrasions that make family life feel true. Giving up hope isn’t defeat so much as a craft decision - surrendering the fantasy that a single household can stand in for a whole country without becoming a schematic.
“Other people’s weirdness” is the key tell. Franzen’s subtext is that readers don’t connect to fiction because it flatters their normalcy; they connect because it dignifies the private oddities they’ve been trained to hide. The phrasing makes weirdness communal, almost tender: mine is too specific to be patriotic, but it’s close enough to yours to feel like recognition. That’s a quietly radical claim in a culture that keeps trying to package family as an uplifting brand.
Contextually, this sits neatly in the Franzen era of big, social novels haunted by realism’s old ambition: to map America through domestic life. Postwar writers could still pretend there was a mainstream to represent. Franzen writes after that mainstream has splintered - by class, by region, by media bubbles - so “the American family” becomes less a subject than a marketing demand. His solution is to go narrower, stranger, more intimate, and let the aggregate of those distortions do the representative work he can’t do directly.
“Other people’s weirdness” is the key tell. Franzen’s subtext is that readers don’t connect to fiction because it flatters their normalcy; they connect because it dignifies the private oddities they’ve been trained to hide. The phrasing makes weirdness communal, almost tender: mine is too specific to be patriotic, but it’s close enough to yours to feel like recognition. That’s a quietly radical claim in a culture that keeps trying to package family as an uplifting brand.
Contextually, this sits neatly in the Franzen era of big, social novels haunted by realism’s old ambition: to map America through domestic life. Postwar writers could still pretend there was a mainstream to represent. Franzen writes after that mainstream has splintered - by class, by region, by media bubbles - so “the American family” becomes less a subject than a marketing demand. His solution is to go narrower, stranger, more intimate, and let the aggregate of those distortions do the representative work he can’t do directly.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Jonathan
Add to List
