"When I was a little boy, they called me a liar, but now that I am grown up, they call me a writer"
About this Quote
There is a neat little revenge tucked into Singer's line: the same impulse that earned punishment in childhood gets repackaged as prestige in adulthood. He’s not just cracking wise about growing up; he’s pointing at a social sleight of hand. Communities love truth as a moral ideal, but they police it as a practical nuisance. A child who invents stories is “lying” because his inventions disrupt the household’s demand for order and predictability. An adult who invents stories is a “writer” because those same disruptions can be marketed, praised, even taught.
Singer, a Yiddish novelist steeped in the moral pressure of tradition and the cataclysm of immigrant modernity, knows how unstable the border is between fabrication and insight. The subtext isn’t “writers lie.” It’s that societies decide after the fact which fictions count as valuable. The label changes because the audience changes: childhood is judged by obedience, adulthood by output. What was once a character flaw becomes a professional skill.
The line also smuggles in a defense of imagination. Calling a child a liar is a way of narrowing reality to what adults can verify. Calling an adult a writer is a way of admitting that reality alone doesn’t explain us, especially in the kind of world Singer chronicled: one where memory, folklore, faith, desire, and trauma all compete to define what “really happened.” The joke lands because it’s uncomfortable: we haven’t stopped distrusting inventors. We’ve just learned to pay the ones who can make their lies feel like truth.
Singer, a Yiddish novelist steeped in the moral pressure of tradition and the cataclysm of immigrant modernity, knows how unstable the border is between fabrication and insight. The subtext isn’t “writers lie.” It’s that societies decide after the fact which fictions count as valuable. The label changes because the audience changes: childhood is judged by obedience, adulthood by output. What was once a character flaw becomes a professional skill.
The line also smuggles in a defense of imagination. Calling a child a liar is a way of narrowing reality to what adults can verify. Calling an adult a writer is a way of admitting that reality alone doesn’t explain us, especially in the kind of world Singer chronicled: one where memory, folklore, faith, desire, and trauma all compete to define what “really happened.” The joke lands because it’s uncomfortable: we haven’t stopped distrusting inventors. We’ve just learned to pay the ones who can make their lies feel like truth.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Isaac
Add to List

