"When Joan D' Arc was asked by her judges why as a Christian she did not love the British, she answered that she did love them, but she loved British in their country. In the same way, we do not hate the Turks, we love them, but in their country"
About this Quote
Le Pen reaches for sainthood to launder a hard nationalist demand into something that can pass as civility. By invoking Joan of Arc, he drafts a ready-made French icon of purity under siege, then smuggles in a contemporary target: immigrants, recast as an occupying force. The supposed lesson is not theological or historical; it is administrative. Love becomes a euphemism for removal, and the border becomes the place where “affection” is safely stored.
The line works because it flips the moral script. “We do not hate” preemptively disarms accusations of racism while keeping the desired policy outcome intact: Turks belong elsewhere. It’s the rhetorical two-step of modern ethno-nationalism: deny animus, affirm separation. The phrase “in their country” does all the heavy lifting, turning people into geography and belonging into inheritance. The imagined politeness is a weapon; it allows exclusion to be framed as manners.
Historically, the Joan reference is slippery. Joan fought English armies in a dynastic war, not a debate about multicultural citizenship. Le Pen collapses military conflict, religious identity, and modern migration into one melodrama of “us” versus “them,” where France is perpetually on trial by outsiders. The subtext is clear: Frenchness is not a passport or participation; it’s bloodline and soil. That’s why the quote endures as a far-right template: it offers emotional cleanliness, even as it argues for ethnic sorting.
The line works because it flips the moral script. “We do not hate” preemptively disarms accusations of racism while keeping the desired policy outcome intact: Turks belong elsewhere. It’s the rhetorical two-step of modern ethno-nationalism: deny animus, affirm separation. The phrase “in their country” does all the heavy lifting, turning people into geography and belonging into inheritance. The imagined politeness is a weapon; it allows exclusion to be framed as manners.
Historically, the Joan reference is slippery. Joan fought English armies in a dynastic war, not a debate about multicultural citizenship. Le Pen collapses military conflict, religious identity, and modern migration into one melodrama of “us” versus “them,” where France is perpetually on trial by outsiders. The subtext is clear: Frenchness is not a passport or participation; it’s bloodline and soil. That’s why the quote endures as a far-right template: it offers emotional cleanliness, even as it argues for ethnic sorting.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Jean-Marie
Add to List









